Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Search results

  1. C

    Does a battery ever have a positive ROI with net metering

    Interesting. That's a lot higher running/peak ratio than regular HVAC. If your particular system only pulls 2kW max then it seems excessive to design backup for 10x that.
  2. C

    Does a battery ever have a positive ROI with net metering

    So, that's 26kW+ peak (21kW+ continuous @ 80% of peak) for heating? I don't know much about GeoThermal but I thought it's supposed to be efficient so the electricity requirement is surprising to me. Running batteries or generator even for 21kW of heating seems very inefficient. Have you...
  3. C

    Does a battery ever have a positive ROI with net metering

    We should just all work to get the POCO's to raise rates as much as possible :cool:
  4. C

    Does a battery ever have a positive ROI with net metering

    Did you get a quote for Enphase battery? It would be interesting to see what financial ROI Enphase thinks you would get with a battery.
  5. C

    Tesla Says I Can Only Get *ONE* Powerwall bc of my Utility's Rules

    True but that's not really different with or without PV. Putting 2 heaters on the same circuit is the real problem. Similar to the risk of people putting extension cords on extension cords. A small PV makes little difference to such risks.
  6. C

    Tesla Says I Can Only Get *ONE* Powerwall bc of my Utility's Rules

    Sorry I don't see any part of the circuit carrying 20A. I can see 16A at most supplied from the 15A breaker and that should trip it at some point.
  7. C

    Tesla Says I Can Only Get *ONE* Powerwall bc of my Utility's Rules

    This is has been done in Germany for a while now. No permit, no inspection, no interconnection agreement ... no problem. No need for US to wait. One reason why residential solar cost in Germany is half of US. IIRC, those guys are dealing with much higher (>>800W) power systems. Are you...
  8. C

    Tesla Says I Can Only Get *ONE* Powerwall bc of my Utility's Rules

    Did the off-grid system require permit and inspection?
  9. C

    Powerwall Reset During Grid Outage

    It would be very unusual if Tesla is triggering overload fault based on voltage. For failsafe overload/short-circuit protection it's typically based on current. However, Tesla could be using a similar type of inverse definite minimum time (IDMT) curve for current. For any overload fault...
  10. C

    Powerwall Reset During Grid Outage

    Sure but then they should be able to provide at least the threshold that was violated given that they actually take the time to record and report the fault.
  11. C

    Powerwall Reset During Grid Outage

    A bit surprising that they would not know the surge level that caused a shutdown.
  12. C

    SPAN.io and Powerwall interface

    It appears that SPAN uses the unsupported API on the Tesla Gateway. You may want to troubleshoot the Gateway based on the info here SPAN - Smart Electrical Panel.
  13. C

    Powerwall Reset During Grid Outage

    So, the hot hub is one of the backed up loads? Are these loads new after the PW's were installed? If so, the overload explanation would seem more plausible. The graphs do appear to show a pretty large power swing on the PW's right before they went down. Also, there is an alert for under...
  14. C

    MASTER THREAD: Powering house or other things with Model 3

    It's risky to assume the external DC-DC current control will work as expected. Unless you know the specific impedances of the power station input and DC-DC output are compatible the MPPT can easily end up pulling the voltage way down. Fixed voltage and current supplies typically work much...
  15. C

    MASTER THREAD: Powering house or other things with Model 3

    1500W should be okay for inrush. What's the DC charging current limit in the power station? Does it have adjustable control for DC charging current?
  16. C

    CPUC NEM 3.0 discussion

    Thank you CPUC ... that's a nice return on the lobbying spend
  17. C

    CPUC NEM 3.0 discussion

    https://a12.asmdc.org/press-releases/20240214-assemblymember-connolly-introduces-legislation-save-california-solar
  18. C

    CPUC NEM 3.0 discussion

    I am sure whoever runs the DMV get paid well but I doubt the total compensation is anywhere close to $14M:
  19. C

    CPUC NEM 3.0 discussion

    Another reason why even the DMV is 10x better than IOU's. IOU's claim they don't have money to fix problem so they have to raise rates while spending plenty of money for lobbying and propaganda commercials.
  20. C

    PowerWalls didn't kick in for power failure due to "grid out of compliance"?

    That makes no sense. It would make more sense if Tesla said the gateway switched to the PW's due to the log message. The grid impedance thing looks a like red herring.
  21. C

    CPUC NEM 3.0 discussion

    Still 10x+ better than IOU's.
  22. C

    CPUC NEM 3.0 discussion

    Exactly. The state needs to take over.
  23. C

    CPUC NEM 3.0 discussion

    IOU investors?
  24. C

    PG&E EPSS and generator options

    Thanks for the info. Can you clarify how you determined the idle consumption? Does the comparison account for DC-AC conversion efficiency for the inverter? Assuming your 400W nighttime consumption is AC power and the inverter efficiency is 90% (optimistic at low load to max power ratio) then...
  25. C

    PG&E EPSS and generator options

    Interesting comparison. One thing missing I see is not accounting for self consumption of the power station. Given the size of it I would be surprised if it's < 100W. Apparently Zendure has quite high self consumption well above 100W. Assuming 100W self consumption, the power station won't...
  26. C

    Voltage Offgrid

    You can pick a few loads you are concerned about and measure the current on vs off grid to see the difference. Frankly, I doubt you will see loads drawing much more current at 240V vs 252V. For large resistive loads (e.g. electric dryer/oven) you will likely see noticeably higher current draw...
  27. C

    PG&E EPSS and generator options

    Thanks for the explanation. Frankly, that is not AC coupling. Many inverters can already sync to the grid and provide power in parallel with grid or charge from the grid. A great feature but that's not AC coupling. AC coupling requires having the ability to curtail power from grid-tied...
  28. C

    PG&E EPSS and generator options

    Look forward to further updates on the unit. It would be impressive if it actually has working AC coupling (i.e. frequency shifting control of grid-tied inverters) off-grid as advertised. A potential red flag so far is that there seems to very little documentation available with no mention of...
  29. C

    CPUC NEM 3.0 discussion

    Are you confident they will actually honor the warranty if you need a replacement? https://diysolarforum.com/threads/shenzhen-basen-docan-quotes.39640/post-647970 IMHO, aside from the often opaque/unresponsive seller communications, there are just too many horror stories with...
  30. C

    Discussion: Powerwall 3 [Speculation / Discussion etc]

    That's false advertising for anything but double-conversion online UPS. It's a bit surprising to see given all the forum reports about interruptions. Perhaps you can file a claim with Tesla and get them to buy online UPS's for the affected loads.
  31. C

    Discussion: Powerwall 3 [Speculation / Discussion etc]

    Where is that from? Can you provide a link?
  32. C

    Discussion: Powerwall 3 [Speculation / Discussion etc]

    Why did you think that?
  33. C

    California Utilities Plan All Out War On Solar, Please Read And Help

    The reality is that politicians survive on other people's money. My questions is how much did the solar/green/clean industry companies/groups contribute to Newsom's campaign? Frankly, I think the solar equipment companies (Enphase alone had $100M+ profit in 2023) could have easily contributed...
  34. C

    California Utilities Plan All Out War On Solar, Please Read And Help

    I applaud the letter and effort. The points are about IOU's and exec's are great but pretty well known at this point. IOU's rightfully work for their shareholders to grab as much profit as possible. That's their job. OTOH, CPUC is supposed to work for the ratepayers and stop the IOU greed...
  35. C

    CPUC NEM 3.0 discussion

    And you have no real warranty at that price. Most battery warranty is only 10 years or less. So, counting on a 10+ year loan for ROI is risky. Also, many people don't stay at the same place longer than 10 years.
  36. C

    CPUC NEM 3.0 discussion

    Looks all the shady sales people from mortgage and pharma industries moved over to solar.
  37. C

    CPUC NEM 3.0 discussion

    State/local governments should own most distribution/transmission networks just like other major critical infrastructure (e.g. roads, water, etc.) instead of for-profit monopolies.
  38. C

    Battery's & Audiophiles

    ... like some people with their solar/battery systems :cool:
  39. C

    How Do I Responsibly Report a Powerwall 2 Hardware Safety Defect?

    My understanding is that grid interconnection requires 600V class rating.
  40. C

    Wondering about generator use with Solar Roof and Powerwalls

    Is your 7kW generator an inverter generator? And is 7kW rating continuous? If so, if you turn off the solar, all loads and turn on only 1 PW (no export allowed mode) then it may work. The generator would substitute for the grid.
  41. C

    SPAN - Smart Electrical Panel

    What's SPAN's support policy if Tesla removes the API entirely?
  42. C

    How Do I Responsibly Report a Powerwall 2 Hardware Safety Defect?

    Can the spark get over to the nearby battery cells?
  43. C

    Optimizers... what are they good for?

    Other M series models (e.g. M250) should also work.
  44. C

    Optimizers... what are they good for?

    I look at it regularly but certainly as often as I used to. It's very useful to uncover an expected seasonal shading from chimney early on (and move the panel) and periodically determine when trimming of certain trees is needed. I doubt IR camera would help much with that.
  45. C

    Charging cable overheats

    No doubt Hubbell is a better outlet design but other UL listed outlets can also work safely with proper wiring and connection. Certainly outlets with larger contact area will be more tolerant to inadequate wiring and connection but that's not really a valid substitute proper wiring and...
  46. C

    Optimizers... what are they good for?

    It could worthwhile but only if "all else being equal". I would need the same level of cost savings but with 25 year warranty, owner accessible support and panel level monitoring to seriously consider it.
  47. C

    Optimizers... what are they good for?

    I would beg to differ Not sure it's practical to separate. Not worth 5x but Enphase vs Growatt is not really a good comparison. One main reason that people pay for Enphase is the support. Owners can easily contact Enphase to get warranty replacement. Can you do that with Growatt? A more...
  48. C

    Optimizers... what are they good for?

    Who makes that? Doubt that's a tier 1 grid-tied solar inverter vendor in the US. A cost comparison of same tier vendors would be more useful. Also, the Enphase cost includes 25 year warranty. Does the string inverter cost include that?
  49. C

    Charging cable overheats

    I guess your electricians never make mistakes?