Since you can order Continental Extreme DWS06 in 195-55/16 for front and 225-45/17 for rear, I would strongly recommend them. I believe they’re the best all-around quieter tire for the Roadster, while still maintaining summer performance.
Second on the DWS06.
I switched a couple of years ago on all my cars.
For the roadster, I drive cold mornings and definitely did not want to take the risk on the Yokohamas. Plus the Yoks were making me deaf, it was to the point driving wasn't enjoyable.
Impressions on DWS06:
1. super, super, super quiet
2. Obviously not a sport summer tire, you will lose feedback as sidewalls are a bit softer. However, after feeling a bit disconcerting initially, you learn to drive with these tires after a while and you realize they stick like glue. Car never understeered since I had them. I wouldn't track with them, but you can hammer them in turns with confidence. You just need to spend time with them and learn the feedback.
3. I like them as the roads in NJ are often "not ideal" and these tires dig into the various textures we have find ourselves in
4. The fronts are just ok/ugh at OEM psi, but play with inflation; +5-8psi and these tires are transformed to a Much better tire
5. Regarding traction, I put these on a g37 after trying all sorts of all seasons. I don't drive the roadster in snow, but the g37 just plowed through snow better than any performance all season I have had. Amazing in deep rain. Plan to put them on my R-design next and lose the really poor P7s (which are not sport ASs). I've never had a better all season, not even close.
6. I would definitely check out the Michelin AS 3+, these have great reviews and should give slightly better dry sport traction. If anyone has these, feedback would be welcome
7. DWS06 has a stiffer sidewall (good) than the original DWS
8. As with all tires, don't judge them before the first few hundred miles are over. They definitely transform for the (far) better as they age. But as you all know, these are not summer sport tires (and the good and bad associated with them)