Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

2017 Investor Roundtable: TSLA Market Action

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Let's take this to oil thread, but horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing only speed up production, they do not magically increase reserves.

My understanding is that shale reserves ex-US are not as prolific as Permian....
.
I do not think this is entirelycorrect.

Reserves can and do rise abruptly, when new sources are discovered and proven. Horizontal drilled, of course, typically exists only where reserves are already known, fracking is another case entirely.
Shale reserves are being found in several places that had not been previously identified.
All places have susceptibility to booms and busts.
What we do know is that North American shale exploitation and new production areas around the world are all acting to reduce petroleum prices. As demand stabilizes or even reduces the pricing will have more downward pressure.

Impact on Tesla or BEV in general? I suggest not much because the absolute efficiency improvements and cost decline in BEV will continue to make BEV better and cheaper. Even public utilities will benefit long term as BEV power demand is proportionally greater at time when overall energy demand is lower. Then, lower BEV maintenance costs will have another virtuous cyclical effect.

...
Taking Permian performance, and extrapolating to the world, is misleading.
This one is, by definition, valid!

I'll argue that any sudden petroleum price drops will probably produce temporary incremental TSLA shorts, and direct share price pressure too. That is simply because conventional wisdom says BEV sales are inversely influenced by declining petroleum prices 'at the pump'.
Short term market models should always incorporate oil and gas news. Long term, it really does not matter so much.
 
Bots are over 75% of volume in EVERY stock on any given day, last I checked (and it's probably higher now). The market makers are mostly bots. Of the bots, a substantial majority are momentum-based... many more are technicals-based...

Things work very differently in the long run. Earnings reports and news act as corrections to the momentum-bot-based trends. Unfortunately the news-bots are even more destructive to market dynamics. But over the long run the slow moves of big long-term strategic holders (like Tencent) overwhelm the bot movements.

That long run is pretty long, though.
so is Tesla notorious for missing earnings by 2X and having a dramatic recovery because:

A) the future's so bright

or

B) there's a single bot that was following a trend line and keeps recovering it

please see my chart above... this stock has continuously held exactly on that line...

so let me ask you this: if this was simply a buyer acquiring a long term position... why would they recover the price back to the original trendline instead of buying low?... i mean... they were sufficiently accumulating before right?... so why would they just buy it back up to exactly the same trendline.

this is not a buyer... and it's not shorts... short interest is flat... this is price manipulation.

another question: is Elon and Tesla a success because of the business or because of the $50b+ market cap?... if the market cap was $10b... do you think anyone would care about this "story"?

that's motive.
 
so is Tesla notorious for missing earnings by 2X and having a dramatic recovery because:

A) the future's so bright

or

B) there's a single bot that was following a trend line and keeps recovering it

please see my chart above... this stock has continuously held exactly on that line...

so let me ask you this: if this was simply a buyer acquiring a long term position... why would they recover the price back to the original trendline instead of buying low?... i mean... they were sufficiently accumulating before right?... so why would they just buy it back up to exactly the same trendline.

this is not a buyer... and it's not shorts... short interest is flat... this is price manipulation.

another question: is Elon and Tesla a success because of the business or because of the $50b+ market cap?... if the market cap was $10b... do you think anyone would care about this "story"?

that's motive.
This guy..
its all about those bank bots expending so much capital elevating the SP so GS or whoever can run book-runner fees on a huge 1bill cap raise (reminds me of austin powers and 1 millllllllioooonnnn dollars!).

lol
 
Last edited:
  • Funny
Reactions: neroden and MikeC
I do not think this is entirelycorrect.

Reserves can and do rise abruptly, when new sources are discovered and proven. Horizontal drilled, of course, typically exists only where reserves are already known, fracking is another case entirely.
Shale reserves are being found in several places that had not been previously identified.
All places have susceptibility to booms and busts.
What we do know is that North American shale exploitation and new production areas around the world are all acting to reduce petroleum prices. As demand stabilizes or even reduces the pricing will have more downward pressure.

I agree with the bolded statement, but what I am suggesting is that the shale reserves that are being discovered around the world, due to geological reasons, are not expected to be as productive as Permian (which by the way, has proven to be full-cycle unprofitable so far, and full-cycle economics in Bakken/Eagle Ford are even worse), with the exception of Vaca Muerta. This is not enough to make up for the accelerating depletion (not decline) rates in conventional supply across the world (including the US).


Impact on Tesla or BEV in general? I suggest not much because the absolute efficiency improvements and cost decline in BEV will continue to make BEV better and cheaper. Even public utilities will benefit long term as BEV power demand is proportionally greater at time when overall energy demand is lower. Then, lower BEV maintenance costs will have another virtuous cyclical effect.

I agree in the longer term. In the shorter term, however, as you mentioned, TSLA still (to my surprise) has some correlation to oil prices.
 
EM on Twitter:
Tesla solar glass roof orders open this afternoon. I think it will be great. More in about 10 hours ...
Get ready for an exciting day. Musk just tweeted that solar roof orders go online today.

Elon Musk on Twitter

There may be many outside of TMC unable to distinguish between announcements about solar "roofs" and solar "panels". In fact some people may think it was an announcement about solar roofs for cars rather than homes. So share price reaction may be developing more slowly than we might have expected today.

 
Last edited:
FYI everyone:

Expect increased volatility at 10:30 am due to EIA's weekly oil inventories report. Offshore drillers are already reacting to last night's API report, which showed a meaningful total product (oil + gasoline + distillate + other) draw.

I expect any impact to be transitory, unless the crude draw comes in at or more than 6-7mb, which would be unseasonal, and may cause a $1-2 jump in oil prices, and ignite the short squeeze. This is a long shot, but we'll see in a minute.
 
FYI everyone:

Expect increased volatility at 10:30 am due to EIA's weekly oil inventories report. Offshore drillers are already reacting to last night's API report, which showed a meaningful total product (oil + gasoline + distillate + other) draw.

I expect any impact to be transitory, unless the crude draw comes in at or more than 6-7mb, which would be unseasonal, and may cause a $1-2 jump in oil prices, and ignite the short squeeze. This is a long shot, but we'll see in a minute.

Crude draw 5 mb, products 2 mb. This is supportive of oil prices, but not a game-changer.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Reactions: everman and Runarbt
I agree with the bolded statement, but what I am suggesting is that the shale reserves that are being discovered around the world, due to geological reasons, are not expected to be as productive as Permian (which by the way, has proven to be full-cycle unprofitable so far, and full-cycle economics in Bakken/Eagle Ford are even worse), with the exception of Vaca Muerta. This is not enough to make up for the accelerating depletion (not decline) rates in conventional supply across the world (including the US).




I agree in the longer term. In the shorter term, however, as you mentioned, TSLA still (to my surprise) has some correlation to oil prices.
Yes, I agree with this post. The fundamental oil issues, though, have fairly modest impact on short term prices, which are the ones that affect short term TSLA. Frankly, I add a few political issues to my short term factors, although I'll not disclose my weightings.
1. BEV subsidy/incentive changes, anywhere;
2. changes in taxes/envirnmental rules for oil/gas retail distribution;
3. Political changes (domestic or international) for Russia, Venezuela, Iran, Iraq, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Nigeria with lesser note for US, Canada, Brazil;
4. Announcements of possible technological advances in exploration/production/distribution
All of those make enough impact in short term sentiment that they act to motivate superficial short term traders, IMHO. My own charts show them to be pretty decent very short term predictors.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ValueAnalyst
Oil prices are moving up following the bullish EIA report, increasing pressure on TSLA shorts.

We'll see if the oil price action, combined with further Solar Roof news later today, will be enough to push TSLA to ATH.

I added to my position. I expect to hold all of my shares through a potential short-squeeze.
 
Last edited:
  • Disagree
  • Like
Reactions: Runarbt and DaveT
on track to test all time high today:

upload_2017-5-10_11-21-26.png
 
  • Informative
Reactions: TMSE
Anybody else buying weekly calls to try and play the solar roof ordering open?

I bought a 325 call near the open.

I actually got puts. We are at the top end of the BB, the top end of EVERY band since we are essentially at the ATH. I also don't really know what the solar roof website will say that will make the market happy. As far as I can tell it will just have the ability to order, and presumably pricing. That isn't really earthshattering in the best case (here I am just speaking for the dumb market momentum) and could even be perceived as bad if it is seen as too high (not competitive) or too low (not profitable). So this smells like a sell-the-news event.
 
I actually got puts. We are at the top end of the BB, the top end of EVERY band since we are essentially at the ATH. I also don't really know what the solar roof website will say that will make the market happy. As far as I can tell it will just have the ability to order, and presumably pricing. That isn't really earthshattering in the best case (here I am just speaking for the dumb market momentum) and could even be perceived as bad if it is seen as too high (not competitive) or too low (not profitable). So this smells like a sell-the-news event.

might buy a couple may 19th lottery tickets if we touch ATH today.
 
I actually got puts. We are at the top end of the BB, the top end of EVERY band since we are essentially at the ATH. I also don't really know what the solar roof website will say that will make the market happy. As far as I can tell it will just have the ability to order, and presumably pricing. That isn't really earthshattering in the best case (here I am just speaking for the dumb market momentum) and could even be perceived as bad if it is seen as too high (not competitive) or too low (not profitable). So this smells like a sell-the-news event.
When did solar roof become the event that is driving the 2017 PPS? Did I miss something?
 
  • Like
Reactions: ValueAnalyst
Status
Not open for further replies.