They are reading in the mid to high 500's over 5 mile intervals, sometimes into 600's.
The fact of the matter is that the "mileage" you see depends on a whole bunch of factors which have been enumerated here many times. In general, aggressive city driving (short trips) in cold weather is going to use more energy than timid suburban/rural (longer trips) driving in warm conditions but individual trip usage can be all over the map depending on, for example, head winds. I offer as an example, and only as an example, the following scatter plot for my drives (about 80) since I have had the car (December 18).
The axis closest to the observer is the duration of the trip and the axis perpendicular to that is the temperature axis (30 towards the front and going up to 70 at the corner farthest from the eye. The bottom line from the picture is what I said above in words. Short, cold trips, in general use more energy per mile than longer warm trips but the plot certainly shows exceptions to this rule of thumb.
The only way to really appreciate what is going on is to use some scheme for data collection. I have mentioned TeslaFi before and continue to recommend it but there are other programs out there that do essentially the same thing.
As a matter of possible interest, an analysis of my 80 drives shows that watt hours per mile change by approximately 1.2 Wh/mi/ °F. Thus at 30 °F I find I'm using, on average, 40*1.2 = 48 Wh/mi more juice than at 70. That's appreciable. YMMV. This figure depends not only on the physics (denser air at colder temperature and weather) over which the driver has no control but also on the driver's battery management technique, his driving technique, how he uses the HVAC system etc.