Almost exactly what happened to me. First month, 1,400 miles, rear bumper replaced, minor damage (thankfully), color matched pretty good. Hope you are at A
utocraft Bodywerks or another equally reputable shop.
i complained to Texas Department of Transportation (TDI) and that nudged Geico to finally send me a friendly letter. TDI recommended that i sue Geico. There is a 2 yr limitation period which is coming up real quick for me.
- Check Carfax (my accident is on there).
- Try NOT to get a rental car replacement (this will boost your DVC)
- Get an appraisal. This seems a rip-off ($800 ~) for what will take me 10 minutes to do. i only have Tesla's trade-in value from back then (low-ball offer of $52k within a month of purchase, compared to a purchase price of $83k).
- Get good counsel from your lawyer friends and go it alone. This is what i plan to do after contacting Geico one last time.