Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register
  • The final cut of the 9th episode of the Tesla Motors Club Podcast, featuring Chad Schwitters, the former president of Plug In America, is now available. You can watch it now on YouTube or listen to it on all major podcast networks.

Am I anti-selling my self

Not sure the best title but here is what I have been debating myself for a few weeks now.

Comparing the Model S75 to the Model 3. EAP on both Premium and LR on the 3. Maybe AWD on the S. Different paint color on both.

I was late reserving the Model 3 November 2016. So my first window currently is April 2018 - June 2018 for the LR premium. Up until a few weeks ago I never considered paying for a Model S. Have had some good financial things happen and now am in position to consider model S. From a Financial perspective 25-30k more expensive range is considering AWD on S that I wouldn't get on the 3. This assumes I get the full tax credit on the 3, plus the 3k Maryland credit that is not available on the S. Also considering the .99% financing on the S vs I am assuming 2.9 on the 3. The S would be a larger down payment as I will try to keep monthly payment in both the same.

After the finances it is starting to come down to a worry the the 3 will be to small. In looking at cargo capacity the S has almost as much as my wife's outback. Previously I wasn't concerned because I figure we would take the outback or I would still have my Tundra. I was surprised we could basically take as much in the S as the outback. Now we do put a roof bag on the outback that would seriously hurt the range, but realized we could do most road trips in the S and this wouldn't be true in the 3. S range is 61 to 51 miles less then the LR 3 I just don't know how significant that is for us. Majority of the driving will be commuting to work and local. Maybe 2 - 3 trips a year were range would make a difference.

I am going to Test Drive an S next Saturday so that will help. Won't know the ride difference or seat comfort etc.

I am treating the model 3 as my next car purchase as my current truck is 11 years old and it time. The difference in the S would be a gift/treat to myself for some things that have gone well recently putting us in a much better financial situation.

Will I regret getting the S sooner and not getting a 3? Will I get the 3 and regret not getting the S? These are all things running through my mind on my commute

I know I am rambling and not sure what I am looking for except some feedback and maybe devils advocate. Anything I am not thinking of?
 

arcus

Active Member
Aug 11, 2017
1,306
973
Denton, TX
I am going to Test Drive an S next Saturday so that will help. Won't know the ride difference or seat comfort etc.
Playing devil's advocate here, you know well enough what will happen after you test drive model S :p

Jokes aside, I was in a same boat when I decided to go with S. No regrets, as it is truly a remarkable car. Plus, I kept my reservation for model 3 anyway.
 
don't do it. Don't test drive the ms. I did...and now on a daily basis i keep going back and forth between model 3 and ms. it's truly painful. I was really hoping for a performance version of the 3 but with the timeline for that is next yr, I'll miss that fed tax credit so the difference in price is pretty close. stupid mistake on my part....don't test drive it!!!
 
don't do it. Don't test drive the ms. I did...and now on a daily basis i keep going back and forth between model 3 and ms. it's truly painful. I was really hoping for a performance version of the 3 but with the timeline for that is next yr, I'll miss that fed tax credit so the difference in price is pretty close. stupid mistake on my part....don't test drive it!!!
Ha. Exactly what I am thinking, I am going down a bad path.
 

ForeverFree

Member
Supporting Member
Jul 9, 2015
609
1,386
Sherman Oaks, CA
Whatever you do, don't read this! I'm about to make your slippery slope longer and slipperier.

As long as you're even thinking about MS ... I wouldn't stint on range. Given even a few annual road trips, you should seriously consider seeking an end-of-quarter deal on a 100D.

The MS is a road-trip beast. It easily swallows up our gear for extended golf + mountain biking trips.

However, if you add a roof rack or hitch rack, mileage takes a beating. In cold weather, mileage takes a beating. And, on long mountain uphills, mileage takes a beating. So, if you ski up in Vermont, or even the Poconos, you'll be glad you went big.

When I made my fateful test drive of doom, I originally considered a 60. When the 70 came out, I was ready to buy that. Fortunately, my wife convinced me to go for the 85D and its 270 miles of rated range. Such the right move.

So much so, that I've even seriously considered trading up to a 100D and its 335 miles.

You will never regret it, I assure you. Friends of ours used my referral code to get theirs, and they've been thrilled.

(Another alternative: Find a deal on a new or recent 90D.)
 
  • Informative
Reactions: boaterva
I too was in your situation a little over two months ago. I test drove the S, and found an inventory model and put money down right away. I dont regret it for a second!
We immediately went on vacation and I hauled a 9month old, all his stuff, and then all of the wifes "stuff" no problem. Theres a LOT of room!
I will actually be in Hagerstown on Saturday this weekend at the wifes moms house. If interested, Id let you test drive, and my car doesnt have the DEMO/LOANER restriction on it! Many instances in the DC area, you need to get above 85mph. Let me know if you want to meet up.
There are inventory cars available a lot of times that will give you extra range. I picked up a 90D here in Pittsburgh and it was barely more expensive then a custom 75D. I drive about 40k a year for work, have put on 6k miles in 5 weeks in the car. I have traveled through WV,OH,PA,MD, NC, and VA. No problems with superchargers around the area. There are plenty more being built in your neck of the woods as well.
Example 90D available.
Model S 90D 5YJSA1E29HF214214 | Tesla

Dont forget the 1k referral code bonus. IF you need one, everyone here has one. You can PM me for one as well.

Just let us know when you put your money down after you test drive! ha
 
  • Like
Reactions: AlanSqB
I too was in your situation a little over two months ago. I test drove the S, and found an inventory model and put money down right away. I dont regret it for a second!
We immediately went on vacation and I hauled a 9month old, all his stuff, and then all of the wifes "stuff" no problem. Theres a LOT of room!
I will actually be in Hagerstown on Saturday this weekend at the wifes moms house. If interested, Id let you test drive, and my car doesnt have the DEMO/LOANER restriction on it! Many instances in the DC area, you need to get above 85mph. Let me know if you want to meet up.
There are inventory cars available a lot of times that will give you extra range. I picked up a 90D here in Pittsburgh and it was barely more expensive then a custom 75D. I drive about 40k a year for work, have put on 6k miles in 5 weeks in the car. I have traveled through WV,OH,PA,MD, NC, and VA. No problems with superchargers around the area. There are plenty more being built in your neck of the woods as well.
Example 90D available.
Model S 90D 5YJSA1E29HF214214 | Tesla

Dont forget the 1k referral code bonus. IF you need one, everyone here has one. You can PM me for one as well.

Just let us know when you put your money down after you test drive! ha
If we could find a time to meet up when you are in town that would be great. Where do I find the inventory models that people keep mentioning? Just on the tesla site? I don't see any 90d's so maybe all gone?
 

AlanSqB

Dog Chauffeur
Mar 20, 2015
673
1,038
Gig Harbor, WA
I did 3 separate Model S test drives, one of which was 3 days. I liked the S for the most part (I was honestly trying to convince myself to get it and end the waiting), and I can afford it, but I'm still waiting for the 3. *shrug*
Same boat here, except haven’t gotten the offer to do an overnight.

My patience right now is mainly based on my belief a refresh is imminent. Maybe not a big one, but something. That would either be an opportunity to have the latest/greatest or maybe an even better opportunity to pick up a great deal on an inventory unit.

Told my OA to call back in October. Maybe I’ll have all my issues worked out by then and be ready to either double down on the 3 or live large with the S.
 
Thanks I will take a
I too was in your situation a little over two months ago. I test drove the S, and found an inventory model and put money down right away. I dont regret it for a second!
We immediately went on vacation and I hauled a 9month old, all his stuff, and then all of the wifes "stuff" no problem. Theres a LOT of room!
I will actually be in Hagerstown on Saturday this weekend at the wifes moms house. If interested, Id let you test drive, and my car doesnt have the DEMO/LOANER restriction on it! Many instances in the DC area, you need to get above 85mph. Let me know if you want to meet up.
There are inventory cars available a lot of times that will give you extra range. I picked up a 90D here in Pittsburgh and it was barely more expensive then a custom 75D. I drive about 40k a year for work, have put on 6k miles in 5 weeks in the car. I have traveled through WV,OH,PA,MD, NC, and VA. No problems with superchargers around the area. There are plenty more being built in your neck of the woods as well.
Example 90D available.
Model S 90D 5YJSA1E29HF214214 | Tesla

Dont forget the 1k referral code bonus. IF you need one, everyone here has one. You can PM me for one as well.

Just let us know when you put your money down after you test drive! ha
Thanks when I go to new Inventory that car doesn't show up, but it does when I follow you link
 

Products we're discussing on TMC...

About Us

Formed in 2006, Tesla Motors Club (TMC) was the first independent online Tesla community. Today it remains the largest and most dynamic community of Tesla enthusiasts. Learn more.

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.


SUPPORT TMC
Top