Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Anyone thinking about an VW ID.4 Instead?

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
Seems this is the new norm. Model Y is such a vehicle. Also, Tesla is about to make Model Y in one casting mold. Big question is how do you repair such a vehicle when in an inevitable collision? Do you replace the whole outer shell of the Y?
 
?

the one cast mold is not the entire "outer shell."

Tesla is installing world's biggest casting machine outside Fremont factory - Electrek

If they do cast the entire rear 1/3 of the body as a single piece as Musk claims, then we'll see a lot of "totaled" MYs when they get involved in collisions.

The cost of replacement will be too great so insurance companies will just choose to salvage them.

Elon will soon disclose that the Model Y will also have force fields. Dents are no longer a thing. ;)
 
Looks like the ID.4 cute-UTE from VW will be out around the end of the year. Pre-orders start next month. 2021 Volkswagen ID.4 electric car: Everything we know in advance of full reveal

Things we can expect over the Model Y:
  • Apple Carplay / Android Auto (w/o a $10 charge to use media and map options)
  • CCS supercharging
  • Heated steering wheel
  • Instrument cluster
  • Heads-up display
  • Federal $7,500 tax rebate
  • German fit / finish
  • Nationwide dealership service
I don't expect it to be a Tesla killer, but competition is good and EM is very competitive.
Maybe we will see a CCS adapter and Carplay / Auto support finally. I will be first in line for the LR AWD version.
Missing Price and Range !!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: richyrich
All these other electric cars are in "theory" at this stage. As we all know concept cars do not always execute in the real world. In my opinion I would spend the extra 8-10k to upgrade to a Tesla just for their technology and track record. There sales is proving this since a higher percentage of their buyers are moving up from Hondas and Toyotas.
 
All these other electric cars are in "theory" at this stage. As we all know concept cars do not always execute in the real world. In my opinion I would spend the extra 8-10k to upgrade to a Tesla just for their technology and track record. There sales is proving this since a higher percentage of their buyers are moving up from Hondas and Toyotas.

Pre-orders open on the 23rd with full specs and delivery around years end.
 
VW has a history of poor quality, misleading customers, defrauding govenment regulators and generally being un-ethical.

They tend to be very arrogant as well.
.

Fortunately we're in a forum for a company notorious for poor quality, misleading customers into purchasing "full-self-driving" under the promise it'll be available in two years since 2015, and generally being unethical to both its workers, and the consumers, who the systematically CEO blames for failing to understand Autopilot, nevermind the promise above and the hands-free video posted right on the official Tesla Autopilot webpage.

A VW seems right in line, given your description.
 
Fortunately we're in a forum for a company notorious for poor quality, misleading customers into purchasing "full-self-driving" under the promise it'll be available in two years since 2015, and generally being unethical to both its workers, and the consumers, who the systematically CEO blames for failing to understand Autopilot, nevermind the promise above and the hands-free video posted right on the official Tesla Autopilot webpage.

A VW seems right in line, given your description.
Unethical to its workers? Please elaborate.
 
Fortunately we're in a forum for a company notorious for poor quality, misleading customers into purchasing "full-self-driving" under the promise it'll be available in two years since 2015, and generally being unethical to both its workers, and the consumers, who the systematically CEO blames for failing to understand Autopilot, nevermind the promise above and the hands-free video posted right on the official Tesla Autopilot webpage.

A VW seems right in line, given your description.
Hmmm, then why are you here?
 
  • Like
Reactions: X Fan
Lets first see it on the market, and then decide.
Or is that to simple thinking?
That's pretty much how all other ev competition to Tesla should be seen as.

There are a bunch of compelling alternatives to Tesla coming like the ID4, the Fisker Ocean, etc..

Even the current Tesla competitors have proven they either can't make as many due to battery constraints or just do not sell well.

At this point people should need to see the car on the road to even consider it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DanDi58
?

the one cast mold is not the entire "outer shell."

Tesla is installing world's biggest casting machine outside Fremont factory - Electrek

If they do cast the entire rear 1/3 of the body as a single piece as Musk claims, then we'll see a lot of "totaled" MYs when they get involved in collisions.

The cost of replacement will be too great so insurance companies will just choose to salvage them.

It's the frame that's being cast. Damage in a collision would be just as expensive as the current multi part frame. If the frame can be straightened at a body shop on a frame jig, one piece is likely to be better.
 
$40K is reasonable for a RWD SUV/Crossover EV, now factor in the up to $7.5K Fed tax credit and it's actually quite decent pricing. If the AWD variant comes in at $45K it may sell quite well.

Too bad 0-60 time sucks at 7.8 sec....
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Reeler