Can you fit 19x9.5 over the MY Performance brakes?

[kadify]

Hi! I'm looking at getting some replica r241s and they seem to have two sizes as far as I can see on canadawheels.ca. *

1. 19x9.5 +45mm offset
2. 20x8.5 +35mm offset.

The 19s are on sale at the moment so I was thinking of getting those but I'm wondering if they would fit over the Model Y Performance brakes? I don't have my MYP yet but, living in CO, wanted to get some wheels set up for when it arrives so I can have them changed out the day I go to pick them up.

Would the 19s work? Would I be better off with 20s since they're narrower for winter driving? What tire sizes would I be looking at for either wheel size?

 

[RoBoRaT]

They will fit on Performance Model Y with PuP red brake calipers, assuming they have similar inner diameters to the ones below.

You might want to ask the seller of Replika R241s.

See the Y owners manual or TSportline wheel guide for Y: The Tesla Model Y Wheel and Tire Guide. Complete Tesla Model Y Wheel Specs. - T Sportline - Tesla Model S, 3, X & Y Accessories

I happen to put 19X9.5 +45 (Y Geminis) and 20X8.5 +35 (Model 3 Sportwheels) on my PuP Model Y.

 

[kadify]

They will fit on Performance Model Y with PuP red brake calipers, assuming they have similar inner diameters to the ones below.

You might want to ask the seller of Replika R241s.

See the Y owners manual or TSportline wheel guide for Y: The Tesla Model Y Wheel and Tire Guide. Complete Tesla Model Y Wheel Specs. - T Sportline - Tesla Model S, 3, X & Y Accessories

I happen to put 19X9.5 +45 (Y Geminis) and 20X8.5 +35 (Model 3 Sportwheels) on my PuP Model Y.

View attachment 614860 View attachment 614864 View attachment 614865 View attachment 614866

Thank you! How do I ensure the inner diameter is the same as the gemini wheels? I checked out Tsportline but their prices are so high even with the sale they currently have going on.

 

[kadify]

Ordered the 19x9.5s. Now just have to wait for them to arrive, get some tires and TPMS and then pack them for when I pick up the car!

 

[TomServo]

Wish Tesla would offer the "Stealth Performance" again. I'd buy it, don't need the brakes, tires, wheels, lowered suspension, harsh ride, spoiler, top speed, or less range. $4K to $5K as a stand-alone option for 0 to 60 in 3.5 seconds would be a popular option.

 

[airbrett]

Wish Tesla would offer the "Stealth Performance" again. I'd buy it, don't need the brakes, tires, wheels, lowered suspension, harsh ride, spoiler, top speed, or less range. $4K to $5K as a stand-alone option for 0 to 60 in 3.5 seconds would be a popular option.

I actually want all of those things except the staggered 21" wheels/tires (harsh ride being a function of trading off sport suspension and tires for non-sport, and less range being solved by not getting 21's). Basically the exact same car as is but with 20" Inductions would be my sweet spot.

 

[Painkiller89]

They will fit on Performance Model Y with PuP red brake calipers, assuming they have similar inner diameters to the ones below.

You might want to ask the seller of Replika R241s.

See the Y owners manual or TSportline wheel guide for Y: The Tesla Model Y Wheel and Tire Guide. Complete Tesla Model Y Wheel Specs. - T Sportline - Tesla Model S, 3, X & Y Accessories

I happen to put 19X9.5 +45 (Y Geminis) and 20X8.5 +35 (Model 3 Sportwheels) on my PuP Model Y.

View attachment 614860 View attachment 614864 View attachment 614865 View attachment 614866

Which one do you like the most for your PUP?

 

[RoBoRaT]

Which one do you like the most for your PUP?

I still like how the black Sportwheels look on the Y vs Geminis. But for some reason the 20” Sportwheels with square 255 Michelin Pilot Sport A/S burns more than the staggered 21” Überturnines traveling same road/miles - must be the aero dynamic effect of the turbine vs open face Sportwheels.

 

[kadify]

I wonder if a 265/40 tire would be worthwhile for a 19 inch rim. Slightly smaller BUT wider for a little rim protection from curbing.

 

[DoctorBenjamin]

View attachment 615807

I still like how the black Sportwheels look on the Y vs Geminis. But for some reason the 20” Sportwheels with square 255 Michelin Pilot Sport A/S burns more than the staggered 21” Überturnines traveling same road/miles - must be the aero dynamic effect of the turbine vs open face Sportwheels.

View attachment 615805 View attachment 615806

I'm a little confused. So you're saying that the heavier and much larger 21 Uberturbines give you more range than the 20" induction wheels that are an upgrade from the Gemini's? How is that possible? They're so much heavier than the 20's and require a much bigger tire etc which all reduce range right?

Thank you for your help.

 

[52 16 57 39]

@RoBoRaT

You and I have similar tastes...

 

[RoBoRaT]

@RoBoRaT

You and I have similar tastes...

View attachment 620497 View attachment 620500

It must be PacNorthWestern in us.
That garage looks like our garage in Bremerton.
And, am also interested in softening the MYP suspension - how are the UPP springs?

 

[Montucky]

Ordered the 19x9.5s. Now just have to wait for them to arrive, get some tires and TPMS and then pack them for when I pick up the car!

Hey - I realize this is an old thread, but I'm also looking at the R241's in a 19" x 9.5" +45 size... and not sure of fit on my '21 MY PUP.

Since I think this is what you used for your snow setup, can you confirm a good fit on your Model Y Performance? I was planning on pairing these with Nokian Hakka R3's in 255/45/19's. Thanks in advance!