Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register
  • We just completed a significant update, but we still have some fixes and adjustments to make, so please bear with us for the time being. Cheers!

Canadian CHAdeMO charging

RiverBrick

Active Member
Mar 23, 2014
2,504
1,713
Mount Washington Valley
Looking really good except for that barren patch between the Alberta border and Sudbury.:p

Under the same government program, 35 CHAdeMO are supposed to be installed between Ontario and Manitoba. However, they haven't released the cities yet. Nor do we know the network provider or the model of charging station that will be used (other than CHAdeMO/CCS 50 kW).

Fast-charging stations for electric vehicles coming to Trans-Canada Highway

Companies don't like to acknowledge the elephant in the room, so the articles contains this quote.

This is perhaps the largest infrastructure project for electrical vehicles to be deployed at one time anywhere in the world,” said Elad Barak,
 
  • Informative
Reactions: lukex4

MarcoRP

@MontrealTesla
Sep 6, 2017
4,873
9,016
Montréal
The additional CHAdeMO in New Brunswick that are already functional are in bold.


  1. Saint-Quentin
  2. Eel River Bar
  3. Bathurst
  4. Tracadie-Sheila
  5. Miramichi
  6. Doaktown
  7. Richibucto
  8. Rothesay
  9. Upper Letang.

Counting the installations over the Summer, 16 sites (15 NB Power + 1 Cadillac Fairview) are currently running in NB with the four not in bold to come.
St Quentin is now active. Was opened 3-4 hours ago
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Reactions: Jaff and RiverBrick

mknox

Well-Known Member
Aug 7, 2012
10,103
1,866
Toronto, ON
Don't use the Electric Circuit CHADEMO in Val d'Or, Quebec (Abitibi region) until further notice. There is a mystery of failing CHAdeMO adapters in the area and the common denominator seems to be the adapter failing after a visit to the Val d'Or station.

That is bizarre. If this station is somehow damaging Tesla CHAdeMO adapters, what must it be doing to the electronics of cars with native CHAdeMO ports?
 

RiverBrick

Active Member
Mar 23, 2014
2,504
1,713
Mount Washington Valley
Don't use the Electric Circuit CHADEMO in Val d'Or, Quebec (Abitibi region) until further notice.

The problem has been fixed now. The manufacturer reports replacing a bad component in the station. They are offering a new CHAdeMO adapter and a $100 charging credit to to the Tesla owners known to have been affected by the problem.
 

Phillip L

Gas Passer
Mar 31, 2015
729
574
Owen Sound, Ontario, Canada
The problem has been fixed now. The manufacturer reports replacing a bad component in the station. They are offering a new CHAdeMO adapter and a $100 charging credit to to the Tesla owners known to have been affected by the problem.
Wow. That is very responsible of them.

Even more than before, I think that Ontario should have handed the bulk of ChaDeMo installations to Flo Network or Circuit Électrique rather than fund the KSI mess. Previous experience matters.
 

rypalmer

Active Member
Aug 22, 2014
1,364
1,446
Canada
Even more than before, I think that Ontario should have handed the bulk of ChaDeMo installations to Flo Network or Circuit Électrique rather than fund the KSI mess. Previous experience matters.
You've got the responsibilities of parties involved confused. It's a common thing I've noticed in the critiques of KSI.

FLO doesn't install their own fast charging stations, AFAIK. This is still up to various contractors, municipalities, businesses, etc, to fund and locate these stations. FLO operates the internet infrastructure payment network, customer support services, etc.

AddEnergie manufacturers the stations, and when you buy a station from them, there's a mandatory 5 year Global management service which encompasses the payment network (FLO or branded otherwise), and mandatory prepaid maintenance fees for 5 years. FLO and AddEnergie are effectively the same company (who knows to what degree that is the case, but they seem attached at the hip) and FLO seems to be one example of their white label management service offering. NB Power's eCharge network would be another example.

"Going with KSI" is akin to saying "going with general contractor X" for FLO stations. KSI, opaquely, seems to operate myEVRoute payment and support network but I don't know for sure. It would be fair to say myEVRoute as a payment/support network has been bad but many other criticisms should land upon the hosts who haven't allocated enough electrical capacity to allow these stations to operate at full power, are charging too much for what they are offering. Criticisms about hardware working poorly belong with ChargePoint, as the supplier of the hardware.

What you are correct in saying is that "experience matters" in terms of being a network operator. FLO charges a premium for this -- $750 per fast charging station per year, mandatory 5 year pre-paid subscription. Maintenance fees are $750 per station per year again. (all figures here are from a year-old quote from AddEnergie). I suspect this was not something KSI was willing to play along with, figuring they could do it for cheaper. They were probably right. I'm not convinced AddEnergie has taken enough measures to drive the price of their products or services down. Unfortunately the end result for us now is lacklustre customer service from myEVroute, but I think the province would have had a very difficult time mandating one provider over another given the costs involved.
 

ChooseGreen

Member
Apr 6, 2016
152
158
Ontario, Canada
but many other criticisms should land upon the hosts who haven't allocated enough electrical capacity to allow these stations to operate at full power, are charging too much for what they are offering.

Thanks for your insights Ryan; very helpful. I am having trouble with the statement that I picked out. It seems hard to believe that the geographically diverse set of stations that KSI is responsible for all seem to be limited to ~30 kW or lower. Simultaneously they seem to have the highest fee structure which has to be time-based due to our Ontario regs. The combination of the slow rates and high fees makes for a very high fee for few km of charge provided.

I feel as though if it were site and host-based issues, there would be some good KSI sites.

I'm really hoping I'm wrong on this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RiverBrick

rypalmer

Active Member
Aug 22, 2014
1,364
1,446
Canada
When one goes to the Flo Network site to look up the chargers on their system, the Circuit Électrique chargers come up. What is the connection there?
Same operation. Flo is the bilingual branding that came after Circuit Électrique network expanded outside Quebec, AFAIK.
 

About Us

Formed in 2006, Tesla Motors Club (TMC) was the first independent online Tesla community. Today it remains the largest and most dynamic community of Tesla enthusiasts. Learn more.

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.


SUPPORT TMC
Top