I searched but could not find anything on this. I have a CR subscription which includes online and notifications. I received an email with several new tests, including this one. I cannot post since it goes to my online subscription. Has anyone else seen this?
Rankings:
1) Cadillac Super Cruise
2) Tesla AutoPilot
3) Nissan ProPilot Assist
4) Volvo Pilot Assist
Cadillac Better Score:
- Clear When Safe to Use
- Keeping Driver Engaged
- Unresponsive Driver
Tesla Better Score:
- Capability & Performance
The highest criteria was keeping the driver engaged and unresponsive driver. Since Cadillac uses a camera to determine the driver’s eye position it received the higher score. Also since Cadillac only waited 4 seconds to warn the driver to respond and Tesla waited 24 seconds it received the higher score.
GM only allows use in areas that it has previewed and added to their maps, a positive to CR. Since Tesla allows use on secondary roads, even though it may limit speeds to 45, a negative to CR.
It was interesting that CR viewed Tesla’s impressive ability to keep the vehicle centered in its lane as a negative because it’s easy for the drivers to become overreliant on it!!
Rankings:
1) Cadillac Super Cruise
2) Tesla AutoPilot
3) Nissan ProPilot Assist
4) Volvo Pilot Assist
Cadillac Better Score:
- Clear When Safe to Use
- Keeping Driver Engaged
- Unresponsive Driver
Tesla Better Score:
- Capability & Performance
The highest criteria was keeping the driver engaged and unresponsive driver. Since Cadillac uses a camera to determine the driver’s eye position it received the higher score. Also since Cadillac only waited 4 seconds to warn the driver to respond and Tesla waited 24 seconds it received the higher score.
GM only allows use in areas that it has previewed and added to their maps, a positive to CR. Since Tesla allows use on secondary roads, even though it may limit speeds to 45, a negative to CR.
It was interesting that CR viewed Tesla’s impressive ability to keep the vehicle centered in its lane as a negative because it’s easy for the drivers to become overreliant on it!!