struggling with the decision. we are a family of 3 with a 4 year old (no plans for more kids)
convince me why i should keep my model 3 order and not get a model y
- Thread starter skinsfan
- Start date
You will be fine until the kid gets to be a larger teenager. Even then, you will survive. Car should be fine unless you go camping and stuff like that where you need the room. I wouldn't change until you have a problem. How is it today? What if the Model Y never came out, would you change? Personally I would stay with the 3 and save your $ for college 
JasonR67
Member
Either vehicle would be fine. Model 3 has a ton of storage space. Model Y has more.
If the model 3 has enough space, then it's down to driving position. Sedan or small SUV and if you are willing to wait for the Y production to catch up with delivery.
if your not in a hurry.. Test drive both.
Yes, I am trying for the least helpful post of the year award.. But IMHO they are essentially the same vehicle with different suspension / trunk. I may have stringer opinions after test driving the Y (My wife wants one, haven't ordered it yet, but now that the order fee is down to $100 I am tempted).
If the model 3 has enough space, then it's down to driving position. Sedan or small SUV and if you are willing to wait for the Y production to catch up with delivery.
if your not in a hurry.. Test drive both.
Yes, I am trying for the least helpful post of the year award..
But IMHO they are essentially the same vehicle with different suspension / trunk. I may have stringer opinions after test driving the Y (My wife wants one, haven't ordered it yet, but now that the order fee is down to $100 I am tempted).With a family of 3 or 4, either the 3 or Y is a good car. It comes down to personal preference. They Y has a little more room and sits up higher off the road which would help visibility, which in places like Texas where everyone seems to drive a truck, would be beneficial. The hatchback with more cargo room could also be a plus if your carrying kids sporting equipment or other larger items. The Y has less efficiency, which will be a little less range, but probably not enough to be a factor. The 3 will be a little more fun to drive because its a smaller sports car like vehicle.
DMLou
Member
In my case, it came down to two reasons, although they may not apply to you:
- I can't wait for the Model Y to come out because my current car is probably on its last legs
- I wanted to save about $4000 or so
DeanP
Member
Actually the Y now has 315 mile range. Just got bumped up.
With a growing family, always go for more room. School activities, sports, work around the house, heck ,grocery shopping is easier. I'd go for the Y hands down.
The model 3 is $4k cheaper than the Y, looks better (my personal opinion), is faster, and is more efficient.
If sitting taller, having a hatchback, and having a bit more storage is more important than those advantages then get a Y.
U are going to have to have another 2 kids so the family can have one of each model.
We've done weekends away in the mountains with all of us in our 3 (2 adults, 2 kids). We fit everything in easily, I even boast we fit 2 (inflatable) kayaks in too... One in frunk, one in the lower storage of the trunk - we even laughed as we drove up passing Subarus and Jeeps with kayaks on the roof racks!
Thats EPA testing that got bumped up. My 2020 Model 3 AWD said 322 miles on the website when I bought it, it displays 310, but I actually get less than that, so I would take that range with a grain of salt.
Rojer Lockless
Member
I'm excited to see all the M3's traded in. I'm thinking I might find a good deal on a P3D and upgrade from my LR. Everyone should go get a Y!
Everyone should go get a Y! 
Russinating
M3 SR+
I'd love a Y, but the SR version isn't expected to be out in the US until late 2021 so who knows for UK.
Darmie
Supporting Member
If the car is just for you, Model 3 makes for a very fun to drive vehicle and it would be recommended. Considering that you are buying a car for the family and you are considering the Y, you owe it to yourself to really consider all the benefits that come with a bigger vehicle. The Model Y makes for a better utilitarian type of vehicle that I feel will meet your needs IMO.
Black306
Member
Am I the only one that thinks the Y is kinda ugly? The short front and higher height makes it look goofy. The 3 is more proportioned, imo...
Knightshade
Well-Known Member
Why waste money to get a slower, shorter range, worse-handling version of the car you already have just for a little more storage you don't really need?
I think it is a little bit of a paradigm in my brain. The reason I say this is the Model X has the same issue. Looks bubble like. But maybe that is the best overall design for function. Have you ever been in an X? They are amazing inside. I think the Y will have that similar feel. I think we are used to longer sleeker cars. In reality though, with EV's especially, the designs are not as constrained. I think we will see a shift away from the longer hood. Simply isn't needed.