It was a genuine question. I would be a Seeking Alpha writer if my goal was just to write hit pieces and burn things down.
I of course have no knowledge of your motivation, nor am I claiming any. A short post like #1 just read that way to me. It seemed like a weird comparison to compare "two rear Model X seats look more spacious than two of the middle I-Pace Middle seats". Hence I did not get the same idea as some that this would be more suited for a Jaguar forum, it felt intended for a Tesla audience that might ponder waiting for the I-Pace.
Just letting you know how it read to me. I am more than happy to discuss the questions to the best of my ability, of course, as I have.
I think that the i-Pace should definitely be able to sit 4 Adults without question. I am wondering what the space in between two rear sets could be used for. I was saying I think that middle space *times* two would not equal the rear row of the Model X.
In that concept the middle space certainly can not be used for anything but added inner elbow room and maybe some small items. However, it is not unheard of for European car manufacturers to have excessively stylized rear-seats in concept cars where the middle-seat is sacrificed to allow for a more flamboyant design for the side seats... Hence we don't think we know yet (
@smac?) in what style or format that will actually go to production.
There are of course some rear-bench cars that are available as four-seaters as option or only as four-seaters. This allows for perhaps a small container or a fixed arm-rest in the middle and perhaps deeper/wider bucket seats on the sides, basically a bit nicer rear-seat for two at the cost of no space for three. Often this has been the domain of coupe and cabriolet versions of smaller cars and on the other end, of high-end executive sedans... but not unheard of in the SUV space either (think the likes of BMW X6).
Here is what the five-seating Jaguar F-Pace rear seat looks like. It may or may not give us some relevant hints:
Some more thoughts in the other thread:
Jaguar I-Pace