Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register
  • We just completed a significant update, but we still have some fixes and adjustments to make, so please bear with us for the time being. Cheers!

Doubt:Buy Model S used 2014 or wait I can afford M3

MasterchiefTS

Member
Jan 24, 2019
52
3
Italy
Hi guys,
In the 2020 I would like change my car (ICE City Car) and I would like buy an Tesla. Here in my country Tesla M3 SR+ starts at 49k- I don't want spent so much at the moment of my life. So, you say to wait a MS P85 early 2014 at 35K with 150.000km or wait can afford an M3 used?

Thanks again
 

FatherTo1

Member
Mar 7, 2019
504
344
California
I have an S, but between those two choices I would go with a 3. You're giving up too much with an S that old. A few out-of-warranty repairs on the S and you will have paid for a new 3. The 3 is a helluva car for the money, latest tech, and peace of mind with full warranty coverage.
 
  • Helpful
Reactions: IdaX

mba83

Member
Jan 10, 2019
82
25
Portland, OR
Depends on whether you need the extra interior space / cargo capacity of model S. But if you really want a 3, wait for the 3. They will become cheaper once model Y comes out. But if you decide to get an S, make sure to get a later model, with auto pilot hardware.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Watts_Up

amiral_sub

Member
Sep 20, 2019
117
82
Bordeaux, France
Hi guys,
In the 2020 I would like change my car (ICE City Car) and I would like buy an Tesla. Here in my country Tesla M3 SR+ starts at 49k- I don't want spent so much at the moment of my life. So, you say to wait a MS P85 early 2014 at 35K with 150.000km or wait can afford an M3 used?

Thanks again
I was like you. I found a rare P85+ (very rare in Europe), I bought it: great car.
Pros :
- full options
- smart air suspension
- free supercharges
- free spotify (in Europe, I think it is niot the case in the US)
- large car
- big trunk, big frunk as it is a rwd
- very powerfull
- very fast car on German Autobahns
- panoramic opening sunroof
- drive unit replaced last year (so I have the million miles motor)
- main battery replaced by a "loan" one (so I think I have a very reliable battery)
- aggressive design with big 21" wheels and third part wheels
- very good build quality: no suspect noise, nothing in bad condition, like a new car after 6 years and 208.000km. My friends can't believe it when I say the km !

cons:
- charges slower than model 3 on superchargers (120kW a few minutes then 60kW max)
- no autopilot
- no new games, no netflix, no youtube
- no sentry
- a bit too firm for me
- not very efficient (consums more than a model 3)
- main warranty expired (still drive unit and battery under warranty) : I had to fix a doorhandle

My best friend has a model 3 SR+ : it is a fantastic car too. The choice is not easy
 

MasterchiefTS

Member
Jan 24, 2019
52
3
Italy
Thank you guys. I see Tesla Inventory Italy and Autoscout24 everyday... For the SR I must ask at Tesla through Email? Right?
MS 85 2014 has many problems? If yes, which?
 

Alysashley79

Active Member
Oct 4, 2013
1,194
512
Seattle(ish) WA
if you buy from Tesla direct you should still get some warranty. I ended up with 2 years up to 100k odo. So around 70k and 2 years.

that being said I bought a 12/14 build p85D and paid more than I would have for a base model 3. It’s really about what you want in a car. My preference is the model S.

I also disagree about the price of the 3 going down once the Y is out. I highly doubt this will happen. Many speculated the same would happen with the S once the X was release. (Spoiler...didn’t happen)

FWIW I have ap1 with mcu1 on my car and love it. I drove a 19 75d last week for a few days and didn’t find that the ap was all that different at least in the way it performed. (It didn’t have full auto pilot)
 

MasterchiefTS

Member
Jan 24, 2019
52
3
Italy
if you buy from Tesla direct you should still get some warranty. I ended up with 2 years up to 100k odo. So around 70k and 2 years.

that being said I bought a 12/14 build p85D and paid more than I would have for a base model 3. It’s really about what you want in a car. My preference is the model S.

I also disagree about the price of the 3 going down once the Y is out. I highly doubt this will happen. Many speculated the same would happen with the S once the X was release. (Spoiler...didn’t happen)

FWIW I have ap1 with mcu1 on my car and love it. I drove a 19 75d last week for a few days and didn’t find that the ap was all that different at least in the way it performed. (It didn’t have full auto pilot)
I love computer science and technology so I prefer AutoPilot advanced.. But I can't afford at the moment. While I can afford one Tesla MS 85 2014 at 35K :D Here in Italy it's very difficult find Tesla a good price not like USA :/
 

Battpower

Supporting Member
Oct 10, 2019
1,950
1,931
Uk
For whatever my opinion is worth as a recent Tesla buyer, after much research I decided that even though I am technically competent and spent my life working on cars, parts and support availability is just too much of a lottery. However much I spent I wanted to feel at least a little support in keeping it on the road!

Started off wanting M3, but found the central screen and trunk lid didn't work for me.

Looked hard for 2017 MS based on spec (sunroof, poss. Supercharging) but eventually gave up because of MCU and want to keep option open for FSD.

Decided it had to be CPO car just to get 2 or 4 year wty from Tesla. Found a nice ex demonstrator with 14k miles with FSD and hw2.5 for not much more than the original M3. Way nicer car in my opinion. Had latsest air suspension parts too.

Any way, what I got from my journey is that I feel spending that much needs backup of Tesla Wty otherwise I would be too stressed if anything costly went wrong or couldn't get parts.

So get Tesla Wty on whatever you go for.
 

tranzndance

Member
Sep 10, 2017
487
316
Bay Area
If you wait to save for a 3 you could get a used one and pay less than getting a new one. Have you looked for used 3's?

My kids don't want to be in my 2017 S anymore. It wasn't the case when my spouse had an older ICEV. They now prefer my spouse's 3. They'd probably like the S if it were newer.
 

outeast

Member
Jan 14, 2020
52
48
NY
test drive a 3 and an older S if possible and then decide.

my friend has a 2015 S, I test drove a 2020 model 3 performance on sunday.

I went with a 2016.5 (11/16) S.
 
Last edited:

AustinP

Active Member
Apr 6, 2015
1,155
913
Belgium
These are really different cars.
S is very large compared to a 3. This is for us important (comfort, luggage) but can be problematic eg to park or manœuvre in small streets.
3 definitely has the obviously most recent tech but S from 2014 is still impressive.
I thought I’d switch to a 3 when it would come but ... not... size matters (Godzilla anyone ??? :p)
That being said, there are indeed some concerns around SuC charging speed for the 85 and older batteries. Something of no concern on a daily basis, when “slow charging” at home, but it does indeed increase SuC charge time on our travels.
I’m the optimistic one that believes Tesla is working on fixing this.
I’d recommend you buy from Tesla to get the usual 2 years CPO warranty, though the previous owner will probably have had the usual issues fixed under warranty already.
 

About Us

Formed in 2006, Tesla Motors Club (TMC) was the first independent online Tesla community. Today it remains the largest and most dynamic community of Tesla enthusiasts. Learn more.

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.


SUPPORT TMC
Top