I struggled with this dilemma for a while. Ended up going with 2014 S85, with 120,000 km on the odometer.
I love the car. But it hasn't been cheap to operate. Have had to replace:
- Brake rotors and pads (all 4)
- Parking brake
- Windshield washer fluid pump
- A/C compressor
- One door handle
- Wheel bearing + sway bars
- One upper control arm
I'm also in the process of buying new all-seasons because the ones the (used) car came with were highly worn.
I've only owned it for a year. I don't mind the brake and tire stuff because that's true of any used car. Only the A/C compressor was a weird one. But because it's a fancy car, all the parts cost more than they would on a normal vehicle.
I still love the car and I intend to keep it for years. That's why I'm putting money into it... because I want it to last. But it still sucks getting a new-to-me car and having to do all this.