"Real" winter tires are fantastic! A set of Blizak snow tires on a RWD car (my heavily modified 300 HP 1999 Miata) make it fun to drive in winter vs terrifying on all season and undriveable on Summer performance tires. The only thing better than a set of Blizak snow tires in winter is an AWD car with a set of Blizak snow tires
I didn't quote you for that though, the quote is so I can say I wouldn't trust Consumer Reports if they told me water was wet, or that Denver has lower air pressure than Miami.
I came to this conclusion back in the 90's when cars built in the same factory, on the same assembly line, by the same workers, in the same year got different ratings based on what badge (Mitsubishi or Eagle in the case of the Eclipse / Talon and Mitsubishi or Dodge for the 3000GT / Stealth). If it had the Japanese badging it got a much better rating than the same exact car with a Domestic badging.
Later,
Keith
PS: Location is listed as East Mississippi, but I grew up in Michigan and until I move next month I am actually currently in Indiana... I know snow