It could be quite useful if you aren't producing enough electricity in a prolonged outage. We had fully snowbound panels for 5 days until yesterday-without the production our 3 PWs would be dead in a day or two. Luckily we had full grid power the whole time.what's the appeal aside from not having to run the generator continuously while the grid is down?
I would like to use my Powerwall at night and don’t worry about cloudy days during PSPSwhat's the appeal aside from not having to run the generator continuously while the grid is down?
Now that Tesla is producing their own grid tied inverter, they should make a version purely for generator injection. They should rectify the AC input and inject the power through the grid tied inverter, with programmable loading so that you can optimize the generator usage. Generator auto-start and shutdown based on SOC levels would be required too.From what I’ve been reading about what electronics require, the generator’s Total Harmonic Distortion (THD) rating will probably have to be 5% or less. Conventional portable generators are typically rated “less than 23%”. Inverter generators are closer to the 5% value. But the question is whether that’s close enough for Powerwall use. Maybe some additional UL standards will be needed first. Right now the THD ratings seem to rely entirely on manufacturers’ statements. And there may be technical factors other than THD that enter into Tesla’s slow walking this so far.
From what I’ve been reading about what electronics require, the generator’s Total Harmonic Distortion (THD) rating will probably have to be 5% or less. Conventional portable generators are typically rated “less than 23%”. Inverter generators are closer to the 5% value. But the question is whether that’s close enough for Powerwall use. Maybe some additional UL standards will be needed first. Right now the THD ratings seem to rely entirely on manufacturers’ statements. And there may be technical factors other than THD that enter into Tesla’s slow walking this so far.
Why would I ever want to charge PW's from a generator?I agree that all of this THD data is almost completely dependent on what the manufacturers state, and I often wonder how reliable it is. Many inverter generators are said to be under 5%THD, at least the ones that I have looked at, and many automatic voltage regulated generators also make it under 5%, but the devil is in the details, and without a standard, who knows? You need a spectrum analyzer to be able to determine THD, and the distortion can change as load shifts.
If the THD is a major issue, running the power over an autotransformer or through some filter circuits would help.
I suspect, but don't know, that the lack of frequency stability in most non-inverter generators may also be an issue, since the powerwalls are used to communicating with solar inverters via frequency shifts.
I look forward to getting a mechanism to incorporate a generator.
All the best,
BG
So that you can run it at a more efficient operating point (energy out vs. fuel consumption) and so that you can have peace and quiet at night.Why would I ever want to charge PW's from a generator?
I do not run my generator at night.So that you can run it at a more efficient operating point (energy out vs. fuel consumption) and so that you can have peace and quiet at night.
My wife goes to bed before me. I like to stay up and catch up on some TV shows. She can't sleep with the generator running.I do not run my generator at night.
That's pretty much it. Oh, that and the ability to be powered while clouds, or smoke impair solar recharging of powerwalls.So that you can run it at a more efficient operating point (energy out vs. fuel consumption) and so that you can have peace and quiet at night.
Why would I ever want to charge PW's from a generator?