I’d like to test drive it, but the goddamn curb weight man! 4600-5000 lbs? My general rule of thumb is that once you cross 3500 lbs, the fun becomes less accessible!
Around 2005-2006, I had the choice of either going for a 545i or the M3 or a 325i with sport pack. Test drove all of them, and it was a close decision between all. M3 fell out of favor, because we had had a kid just then, needed a practical 4 door sedan. 545i with SMG came very very close, but I am not into a lot of power, I need nimble, quick and fun.
325i edged out the others, not only due to the test drive, but due to a recommendation from a friend who used to work in car design for a big auto manufacturer around the time. His opinion is still held highly by me. He knew so much about suspension tuning and handling. Most of my knowledge is due to that guy’s coaching.
I very much prefer to drive my 3 compared to my S. 3 is a lot of fun, but it’s rear isn’t as planted when driving very quickly in the twisties. My BMW was rock solid and fun, never had a doubt it would ‘betray’ me during those fun times. Ever.
Even when choosing my S, I chose not to go for the 85 KWh because a comparison test driv back to back told me the 60, being 260 odd pounds lighter was just a bit more fun to toss around. I equipped the S with very light weight sport wheels (XQ sport wheel each weighing just 22 lbs compared to the stock 29 lbs wheel).
In general, lighter the curb weight, more agile and sporty it might feel.