I just switched over to Farmers from Allstate, the Farmers online quote wasnt that good but an agent said they could do better. I guess Farmers bought out metlife so they added to metlifes group instead and it ended up being the best rate for my home and auto with all the discounts we qualified for.
Just auto Statefarm, Progressive, and Nationwide were pretty good, just their home insurance was 50-100% more and would wipe out any savings. Also i guess there are 2 versions of Progressive, Direct which is the standard online version and something else agents had, mine couldnt come close to the online quote.