I’ve rented several Tesla’s on Turo over the past couple of years; always for road trips. I plan in advance and usually look for vehicles with unlimited (or otherwise generous) miles.
Turo can be hit-and-miss for vehicle owners. Some renters care for the cars as their own, but others treat the cars like a typical rental that nobody cares about. Curb rash and rock chips on the paint are things an owner has to expect to have happen.
Insurance, as mentioned, can be a significant expense to both parties. I have very high coverage through USAA, so as a renter, I always decline Turo’s insurance. As a host, I would want the premium insurance since it covers wear and tear.
Finally, a Tesla can’t be compared to a $50/day ICE car. Many Teslas, especially performance versions, compete with exotics in terms of daily rental pricing.