Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register
  • TMC Podcast #11 will stream live Saturday at 1PM PDT. We will be joined by special guest JT Stukes, a former engineer at Tesla. You can watch it live and participate in the chat on YouTube. We will addressing viewer comments and questions. For more information, follow the TMC Podcast #11 thread.

FSD/ Robotaxis and UNECE Regulations

Forgive me for my ignorance in this area but I was curious if anyone knew- does Brexit mean we will no longer be held to the archaic car regulatory policies of the EU that substantially delay the timeline to receiving FSD here? (I mean the FSD that is being beta tested in the USA at the moment by members of the public- autonomous driving on city streets etc)

Just so frustrating that the regulations we are bound to seem so strict that we may be amongst the last in the world to receive a truly gaming changing technological advancement in the months or years to come.
 

MrBadger

Badger out
Jun 17, 2019
9,303
6,895
Surrey, UK
The Economic Commission for Europe of the United Nations regulations, known as UN/ECE are largely a worldwide set of regulations which any country can sign up to or reject - nothing really specific to the EU. The USA fall under the UN/ECE umbrella, but do not sign up to the regulation 79 (UN/ECE r79) that affects assisted and autonomous driving.

On leaving the European Union, we adopted all European Laws as ours - effectively a cut and paste. But we do now have the option of removing/adjusting them as we see fit which includes the ability to opt out of r79.
 
Last edited:
Vanilla is spot on with his assessment. From my point of view regulations is the least of my worries regarding the implementation of FSD as it is on the beta version right now. From what I have seen so far there is no way this system can cope with UK traffic as it is now.
I believe we will see a more gradual approach over this side of the pond. Some features will get slowly released over the next couple of months maybe.
Don't get me wrong; I love the idea behind it and I have already bought FSD. But I cant see it getting fully implemented in the UK. Maybe on motorways, A roads and simple roundabouts/traffic lights. But city driving will be a massacre.
 
Countries are free to adopt their own rules, which manufacturers can adopt instead of or in addition to UNECE rules. This allows multinationals to just adopt UNECE for all major (non US) markets, or tailor there offering based on local legislation.

This is not dependent upon EU membership. As I understand it Norway (single market member) have already done this (no coincidence Norway flagged as first European country to get FSD Beta by Elon), Germany and UK are currently going through process of this as well.

There could be new rules in UK at end of this year which allow much of FSD to operate here - there are consultations ongoing at the moment
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: Durzel and M3noob
From what I have seen so far there is no way this system can cope with UK traffic as it is now.
I believe we will see a more gradual approach over this side of the pond. Some features will get slowly released over the next couple of months maybe.

The main complication I can see in the UK compared to the USA is mini roundabouts, and yielding rules for those.... that will be interesting to see..... but once that is mastered, then it should be able to do multiple roundabouts too - such as "the magic roundabout", as it will see each roundabout in series simply as a sequence of independent tasks.

Other than that , having seen lots of FSD beta clips on youtube, I'm not sure other that UK roads are any more problematic than anywhere else to be honest.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KennethS

Billbrown1982

TM3 LR 2021 | Red | FSD
Dec 21, 2020
612
353
Basildon
There's clearly two parts to FSD happening in the UK. The first is obviously regulation, I can't see us rushing to fully autonomous cars everywhere for a decade or more. Sure, low speed, motorway only, maybe this year, maybe next. But get in your car and have it take you anywhere... that'll be a lot lot longer coming.

But then there's the tech too. It's in beta because it's buggy, and doesn't work all the time. That'll change over time, but equally I fully expect cars to need changing too. In the UK for example the door pillar cameras get blinded by low sun most mornings and evenings for 4-6 months of the year. That isn't something software can fix.

So given that it's very likely govt/legal changes needed for FSD will put some of the responsibility on the manufacturer, I can see if very likely Tesla will block FSD when sensors aren't working, and so in the UK for a good chunk of the year, current hardware won't be allowed to use FSD.

Much as Elon makes a big thing of all current cars having the required hardware... I'm not sure that'll be true, or even matter much by the time the Government and Software have caught up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DenkiJidousha

Billbrown1982

TM3 LR 2021 | Red | FSD
Dec 21, 2020
612
353
Basildon
There's clearly two parts to FSD happening in the UK. The first is obviously regulation, I can't see us rushing to fully autonomous cars everywhere for a decade or more. Sure, low speed, motorway only, maybe this year, maybe next. But get in your car and have it take you anywhere... that'll be a lot lot longer coming.

But then there's the tech too. It's in beta because it's buggy, and doesn't work all the time. That'll change over time, but equally I fully expect cars to need changing too. In the UK for example the door pillar cameras get blinded by low sun most mornings and evenings for 4-6 months of the year. That isn't something software can fix.

So given that it's very likely govt/legal changes needed for FSD will put some of the responsibility on the manufacturer, I can see if very likely Tesla will block FSD when sensors aren't working, and so in the UK for a good chunk of the year, current hardware won't be allowed to use FSD.

Much as Elon makes a big thing of all current cars having the required hardware... I'm not sure that'll be true, or even matter much by the time the Government and Software have caught up.

I've been wondering for a while though, could that not just be fixed by a polarised lens over the cameras or something to that degree?

Equally, some of the trucks at work don't have mirrors at all now and its all done by cameras, with screens inside the cab. These don't seem to be affected by the sun dazzling them...so whats the difference I wonder.
 
The main complication I can see in the UK compared to the USA is mini roundabouts, and yielding rules for those.... that will be interesting to see..... but once that is mastered, then it should be able to do multiple roundabouts too - such as "the magic roundabout", as it will see each roundabout in series simply as a sequence of independent tasks.

Other than that , having seen lots of FSD beta clips on youtube, I'm not sure other that UK roads are any more problematic than anywhere else to be honest.

Ah, the classic mini-roundabout standoff. It'll be OK during beta I reckon, as the Tesla will likely be overly-cautious and give way to everyone else, or the driver will override it if it's taking too long. The real fun will come when, several years down the line, three robotaxis (with no controls) meet at the same mini roundabout and get stuck :D

Looking forward to seeing a YouTube video of a Tesla successfully navigating the magic roundabout itself when it becomes possible!

I remember reading that the UK was wanting to be one of the pioneers with regard to self-driving car regulations being changed, and then Germany came along and just got it done. Really looking forward to something actually getting done beyond consultations.

The UNECE regulations seem a bit backwards in places. For example, apparently the car may only steer up to a maximum angle automatically, after which it wants you to take over. Seen a few videos of people testing autopilot on UK roads. It seems dangerous to impose this limitation.

I'll be happy in the short-term if we don't have to keep holding the steering wheel whilst on using autosteer or having to nudge it with NoA, and if summon could work further away.
 
  • Funny
Reactions: DenkiJidousha
Ah, the classic mini-roundabout standoff. It'll be OK during beta I reckon, as the Tesla will likely be overly-cautious and give way to everyone else, or the driver will override it if it's taking too long. The real fun will come when, several years down the line, three robotaxis (with no controls) meet at the same mini roundabout and get stuck :D

Looking forward to seeing a YouTube video of a Tesla successfully navigating the magic roundabout itself when it becomes possible!

I remember reading that the UK was wanting to be one of the pioneers with regard to self-driving car regulations being changed, and then Germany came along and just got it done. Really looking forward to something actually getting done beyond consultations.

The UNECE regulations seem a bit backwards in places. For example, apparently the car may only steer up to a maximum angle automatically, after which it wants you to take over. Seen a few videos of people testing autopilot on UK roads. It seems dangerous to impose this limitation.

I'll be happy in the short-term if we don't have to keep holding the steering wheel whilst on using autosteer or having to nudge it with NoA, and if summon could work further away.

Yeah, every .. 15 .. seconds, having to give a sufficient nudge on auto drive.
Not enough and it flashes the screen and barks at you.
A bit too much and it simply drops control over to you without warning that it has let go.

Long time ago apparently it was sufficient to fiddle with the wheel buttons but now you actually have to nudge the wheel itself.
 
The real fun will come when, several years down the line, three robotaxis (with no controls) meet at the same mini roundabout and get stuck :D

Robotaxis will follow driving patterns, so should be predictable.... there will also be car to car communication protocols which are being worked on, which would allow robotaxis to know the others intended path/actions, so this should be easily done.

The main issue I think is actually human drivers, who have random abilities and behaviours.... especially those that see a self driving car and could try to tease it/confuse it deliberately. The more robotaxis/self driving cars on the road, the more safe and efficient the road system will become.

There's clearly two parts to FSD happening in the UK. The first is obviously regulation, I can't see us rushing to fully autonomous cars everywhere for a decade or more.

The Law commission is consulting on new rules and legislation right now, which will optionally be available instead of UNECE regs in the UK. They will be reporting their findings in only 7 to 10 months time. This is going to happen sooner than you think.

Automated Vehicles | Law Commission
 
The UNECE regulations seem a bit backwards in places. For example, apparently the car may only steer up to a maximum angle automatically, after which it wants you to take over. Seen a few videos of people testing autopilot on UK roads. It seems dangerous to impose this limitation.

That's a myth alas perpetuated by Tesla because that's what their implementation does.

The limits are about lateral force around a corner ie. you're not allowed to do sharp corners at 70 and pin your passengers to the doors..

The correct solution is to slow down and take the corner a bit slower. AP lacks the ability to do this so it simply aborts.

The latest drafts actually say you must *not* abort a manoeuvre if you find yourself outside the limits during it as this could be dangerous.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrBadger
So ~10 months for the consultation, and however much longer after that for something to actually follow from it? That doesn't sound like "sooner than you think" to me, to be honest :( It would suggest to me we're not going to see FSD beta in the UK this year.

Agree it wont be this year, but 2022 seems a reasonable bet for UK specific legislation and certainly not a decade wait. In the meantime there could be some UNECE improvements that help things a long a tiny bit.
 
Thanks for all your thoughts everyone! I’m stunned by how much knowledge you have in this area. Really eye opening.

The new firmware for FSD in the States is out and although (so far) it’s night time driving in relatively well lit streets, it’s looking pretty good. This is not even version 9 which Musk anticipates is coming out to even more beta testers next month in the States. When he promised exponential improvement, maybe he wasn’t lying?

Keep an eye out for day time driving videos of the new firmware. Tesla suggest only minor improvements have been made on this firmware but the first tests indicate a definite improvement across multiple areas!

 
This thread FSD Beta Videos (and questions for FSD Beta drivers) was an excellent thread of videos going right back to the start of the FSD City Streets beta. Unfortunately it got taken over by some 'distractions' but if you can read/watch between those, still has some really good insight - a couple of the beta testers contribute directly to that thread.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Mm2021

Products we're discussing on TMC...

About Us

Formed in 2006, Tesla Motors Club (TMC) was the first independent online Tesla community. Today it remains the largest and most dynamic community of Tesla enthusiasts. Learn more.

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.


SUPPORT TMC
Top