Yesterday my TPS went off, pressure low. Checked tires: One at 25 lb. Careful search with soap water to look for bubbles: rusty nail in center of tread.
I have used plugs in tires for 40 years, about when steel belted radials came out. I owned a business that worked with construction, and my trucks, vans and cars had every imaginable tire type on them. I plugged a tire a week, at least.
Over the years, I have noticed that the tire repair companies started to get upset about all these people fixing their own tires for a few pennies in a few minutes. The scary stories started to circulate, then all the tire shops "refused" to put in plugs, because they "ruin the tire", etc., etc.
There may be some people who don't watch the pressures and will run a repaired tire flat, or drive with a nail in a nearly flat tire, but a little experience tells you that, yup, that ruins the tire, but it is NOT the plug or the plug process. In my 40 years of plugging tires, only once have I had a plug leak, and by putting in a second plug, that tire ran it's tread life out on the vehicle. My cars and trucks were in daily use logging in thousands of miles, and using up tread that would have cost thousands to replace, or thousands to take to a tire shop, be un-mounted, checked, plugged and patched inside, re-pressured and remounted. Half the time they screwed up when they did it (you know those TPMS sensors cost over $100 each).
I plugged my tire. I only put it on about a month ago, and it is wasteful to take it off and replace it because of a nail hole. Tire companies rely on fear to get your money. Car companies do the same thing when it comes to brake fluid or charging an electric vehicle. The plug cost me less than a dime. I don't dismount the tire, and I don't deflate it. I do it where it sits. And it will last as long as the other tires.
Learn how to plug your tires. It works, and it works well, reliably. Learn to discount the protectionist babble from the tire companies and tire repair places. They are mainly after your money, despite what they say about "you may die", etc.