Though the thread is stale, my car is still new.

And I just finished my brushed black metal install.... plus a little bling. Man, it came out nice. (And I'll be honest here, I wanted to show it off because my wife sure doesn't care! Didn't even notice.... sigh)
How it eventually comes out depends on how detailed and picky you are. Ain't nobody more picky than I am. Mine looks like it was forged from this fancy black metal. (For the record, and to answer an earlier question in this thread - my detail guy (who wrapped and tinted the car) wanted $125 to do this, but would only do it in the matte black. So I said thanks, ordered from Kenriko and did it in about 45 minutes one cool morning. This is how the car should have come IMO. Beyond the screen, it is the focal point of the interior, and that piano black is just not cutting it. Hell, it was hard to keep it clean just for the few minutes between the wipe-down and the application of the vinyl!
Oh.... I should mention that I removed all my console trim to assure a better job on the sides of everything. Nothing needed to be "tucked" on the sides. I was able to just fold and press with my fingers. Note that there is NOTHING to wrap the edges on the cup-holder part. That concerned the heck out of me until I realized that the faux metal trim on the sides actually covers the edges of the cup holder once reinstalled.