-
Want to remove ads? Register an account and login to see fewer ads, and become a Supporting Member to remove almost all ads.
Bangor Bob
Member
I highly doubt the CHADeMO adapter in the Model S will allow power to be drawn. Tesla will make sure of that. Otherwise people could charge for free at a Supercharger and then power their house or other things for free. That's not going to happen.
This article says "were you to plug the Exporter 9000 into Honda's fuel cell-powered FCV Concept cars, you can get 9kW of electricity out for a solid week." Doing the simple math that would be 16 times the battery capacity of the Tesla 90D.... or almost a 5,000 mile range. Seems unlikely.
CHG-ON
Still in love after all these miles
Tesla only takes power one way: in, not out. It would be awesome though. I have power outages at least 3-4 times in the wet season and they can last 3-4 days some times. So I use a Honda (of course) noisy and stinky gas generator.
islandbayy
Active Member
CHG-ON
Still in love after all these miles
Who knows! We are praying that El Nino brings us the wet stuff this year. The fear is that it will dump all at once, so expect to see us on the news with landslides and floods. I'm preparing my home as much as I can.
It is unbelievably bad out here. If we don't get a lot of rain this year, we will be in deep, deep trouble. So even though we are California hippies, please do pray for us!
It is unbelievably bad out here. If we don't get a lot of rain this year, we will be in deep, deep trouble. So even though we are California hippies, please do pray for us!
JPP
Active Member
Kind of odd--the other day I received a request to complete a fairly detailed customer survey about the Exporter. It proposed several models of the unit (power capability), run times, and cost. None cheap--all $3000-4000. Asked if I would consider this over a standby generator. Did not address the issue of it not working with a Tesla. They even had a video of a cute couple driving a Leaf and using it when camping and for a power failure at home.
OBX John
Autonomous Driving Enthusiast
You'd think it'd be a fairly simple software problem to stop anyone from drawing battery power a supercharger had provided, especially if Tesla sells the output adapter.
How can we know for sure until this unit is tested with the CHAdeMO adaptor? DC chargers have direct access to the battery voltage. It's not unforeseeable this unit will work, provided Teslas don't have active checking for reverse current.
JPP
Active Member
AFAIK there has been no test with Tesla's CHAdeMO adapter, and I would anticipate that it probably would not work (...see post 4 above).
ThisIsTrue
Re-member
While waiting for my car, I read the entire manual. Page 130 of mine (North America) notes:
GlmnAlyAirCar
Active Member
I can't believe this myth is still out there. I know tesla owners are cheap. But is anyone, on a regular basis, going to sit at a supercharger for an hour or so, drive home, throw their transfer switch and run their house off ev power for a couple of days, the whole time being without their car that they are making payments on each month to drive? For what? $10 in electricity?
Plus, the population of free supercharging Teslas is going to shrink over time. Do you really think this is of the slightest concern to Tesla?
The more likely reason for prohibiting this is to prevent premature degradation of the battery. More cycles->more wear. As long as tesla is warranting the batteries they won't want to allow this.
As has been pointed out by @wk057, during DC charging the battery bus is connected directly to the charge port. As long as this connection holds, there should be no reason you can't draw power out of the charge port. Now, the Chademo adapter probably has logic in it to tell the contractors to open if it detects reverse current. However, there is nothing to prevent a hacked adapter (or clone) from lying to the car about what it is doing.
Bigtanuki
Member
I would agree that Tesla would block any attempt to draw post from the battery pack with software interlocks. I expect they would view it as a potential liability issue (California company!!). Since it's a non Tesla piece of hardware connected to a very powerful battery there is a lot they can't control. If you're desperate and silly enough I suppose you could shuttle power from a supercharger to your home in an emergency but why go to the trouble to steal power if you spent that much on a car? That being said there is always a dumbass out there that will do the inexplicable.
Similar threads
- Article
- Article
