We took possession of our CPO in late March. We just got our first insurance bill (I swear this was not the number I was quoted when I called for an estimate before we bought). We have Geico, and they have been great & very competitive. We have $500 deductible for both collision and comprehensive. I do have 2 points on my license from a small fender-bender last year, but the car is in both my husband's & my name (he has no points). We are paying $2000 a year for the Tesla!! Just the collision is $1600. Is this normal??