You can install our site as a web app on your iOS device by utilizing the Add to Home Screen feature in Safari. Please see this thread for more details on this.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Progressive was much less expensive in the NY area
As others say, shop around. Rates vary quite a bit. How much each person pays won't be an apple to apples comparison, of course. We all know that where we live, age, how far we drive, our accident and ticket history, whether we bundle other cars and/or home insurance, education, profession, etc, etc.
All caveats aside, here is a portion of the spreadsheet I made for myself when I recently went to find auto insurance for the new Model S and my wife's RDX. We went with $250k/$300k/$100k coverage (or as close as possible...some insurers had $300K/$300K/$100K and others might have $250k/$500k/$100k). We specified a $1000 deductible.
View attachment 234954
Takeaways (for our quotes - your mileage may vary!):
1) Geico was almost half the price of Allstate
2) Even given AAA's stated raising of Tesla rates...it was basically tied for the second cheapest quote we received. So don't automatically rule them out.
After getting few more quotes, seems like progressive is the cheaper alternative by about $300/6months. Not sure what happened in the last 2 weeks with Geico - guess i just caught them before they adjusted their tesla rates.
I have Travelers for home and auto. The premium for my S90D is $800 for the year.Try Amica, and Travelers..
I live in the same town as you, and found similar relative pricing of many of those insurers. My 2nd car is a bit older, so my 2-car quotes were lower than yours, but Geico was the lowest and my then-insurer Allstate was the highest by almost twice. Progressive and Ameriprise (through Costco) were in the middle. esurance (ironically owned by Allstate) seemed like it was coming in lowest, but it couldn't recognize my Tesla VIN so I could never get a definitive quote online.
Not surprisingly, I switched from Allstate to Geico at the beginning of July.