My lowest TOU rate is from 12-5AM year-round every day. I purposely have dual-chargers and an 80A HPWC, and have never had a problem with regularly scheduled charging not completing on my S90D within that timeframe. (I specifically purchased the dual charger and put in that circuit so I could effectively do a full "fill-up" at lowest rates if I ever wanted to.) As
@animorph and
@WannabeOwner suggest, there are a couple of things that CAN be exceptions.
- The scenario @animorph suggests has bitten me a couple of times when my MS has been plugged-in and not driven for a couple days -- it's started it's "top off" off of my planned 12AM schedule and outside my 5-hour TOU rate window.
- As I've said in other threads, I can understand Tesla's logic why perhaps this exception was originally created back-in-the-day when 40kWh batteries were the norm, but with 85 and 90 now being effectively the standard and perhaps representing a majority of the fleet, Tesla's logic no longer holds together for me. IMHO, unless battery level is so extremely low it's going to possibly damage the pack, I believe Tesla's firmware should just wait to begin any needed top-off until the next scheduled charging time, so those of use that do have TOU rates or maybe are trying to use their own solar, can ensure we always use the lowest rates being applied when top-off is necessary. On my S90D, there is little benefit gaining 7-8 miles in an auto-top-off when I already have more than 240 miles of Rated Range available. While it's pennies difference having that little top-off happen outside my low TOU rate upon occasion, it's one of the little refinements I expect Tesla should keep up with and manage on my behalf. Tesla could get really fancy and have different logic based on the size of the battery I suppose, or offer owners an option, but I suspect you get my POV.
- Of note: With my scheduled charging start time of 12AM, the couple of times I have arrived home between 12:01AM and 6AM, plug-in, and my MS needs a charge or top-off, my MS has NEVER started charging until the next night.
- I don't consider scheduled software updates to be any sort of issue for me, as it's my decision as to when I ask my MS to apply those updates on the rare occasion they arrive, so if they interrupt my charge, that's on me.
As to folks suggesting a "Finish charging by" time which is introduced every now and then in various threads, I agree it may be nice for some -- especially in colder climates, but personally I suspect we'll just have another set of owners that will then complain it does not always work within a reasonable tolerance level. The issue is IMHO, when charging to say my normal 90%, estimating finish time is not rocket science and can generally be accurate within a reasonable margin of error -- so backing-up when to start that charging would be fairly easy. OTOH, at least with my early S90D, I can NEVER estimate the time it takes to trip charge to 100%. The last few percentage points when battery balancing is taking place has taken a handful of minutes to more than 30 minutes, and I have never been able to predict it ...introducing a huge variable that I suspect would make estimating when to start a trip charge difficult for Tesla to calculate... Sure, Tesla could pad that by maybe 30 minutes to hopefully always be done by the time an owner wants, but then we'll have people say their MS is ending it's charge too early or it's not accurate enough.
Ah, consumers. We'll never all be happy.