Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

It's the Batteries, Stupid!

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
Sooooo....what's everyone's take on this? NCA is cars and NCM in storage, so does/will this affect Tesla cars (Model 3 and beyond) now? Tesla hasn't stated what chemistry they will be using for the M3 yet........hmm.

 
Last edited:
Sooooo....what's everyone's take on this? NCA is cars and NCM in storage, so does/will this affect Tesla cars (Model 3 and beyond) now? Tesla hasn't stated what chemistry they will be using for the M3 yet........hmm.

My take is this work is still in the early stages and may not yet be ready for prime time. NCA has a specific energy advantage at current voltages so even upping the voltages of NMC may not make it significantly better than NCA.
 
The Slashdot Interview With Lithium-Ion Battery Inventor John B. Goodenough - Slashdot

Interesting interview. He thinks the new battery design can make it to market in 3 years.

firstly, new battery design can make it to make in 3 years, is due to diversity of the market. there are solid state batteries on the market today with phenomenal properties, doesn't make them suitable for most applications.

2ndly, this is about glass electrolyte, so optimal for button or flat cells, not good for cylindrical.

3rdly, different technology paths were discussed in the review, covering a state of play, not just a single concept.

4thly, it appears to be holy grail - the solid electrolyte. If the temperature issue is solved, then the density improvement can be about a factor of 3X. Ie equivalent to going from the best NiMH 18650 to the best NCA 18650 cell.
 
upload_2017-9-14_3-36-35.jpeg
 
  • Funny
Reactions: EinSV
firstly, new battery design can make it to make in 3 years, is due to diversity of the market. there are solid state batteries on the market today with phenomenal properties, doesn't make them suitable for most applications.

2ndly, this is about glass electrolyte, so optimal for button or flat cells, not good for cylindrical.

3rdly, different technology paths were discussed in the review, covering a state of play, not just a single concept.

4thly, it appears to be holy grail - the solid electrolyte. If the temperature issue is solved, then the density improvement can be about a factor of 3X. Ie equivalent to going from the best NiMH 18650 to the best NCA 18650 cell.
A lot of people seem to agree that Solid State will be the holy grail. Samsung says they will bring the first phone to market with Solid State within 3 years.
 
a fairly typically solid state battery http://www.mouser.com/ds/2/389/efl700a39-973897.pdf
cost is about USD 8.00 per piece.
rough primer on use of solid state batteries.

Goodenough's latest solid state work is crazy even by solid state standards.
It uses a novel effect that seems only relevant for the initial 2-10nm of coating.
nm.

having said that, Goodenough's latest seems to limited only by anode, not by cathode!!!! kinda like a battery sans cathode. surreal.
 
Forgive my ignorance, first post and new to this, but didn't Tesla already do this at a much larger scale in Australia to help out with brownouts....and somewhere else? How old was this video?
I think you are confusing two different products. The MIT video talks about a new type of battery using entirely new technology and not LiOn, that will be much cheaper and can be produced at mass scale. I am fairly certain this is not for automotive usage.

This video is just a few weeks old.