dhanson865
Well-Known Member
He compared it to what he sees in other cars. I don't think he said anything factually incorrect.
And if you had bothered to actually watch the video you would see that they stated that the board was an nvidia.
I've worked in IT pretty much my entire adult life, I know more about computer components than he does. I do think he said some whoppers of incorrectness but I don't think it's worth my time to document them or try to correlate them as though they have any significance other than his lack of knowledge of tech.
As to actually watching the video, I did, multiple munro videos, each time they come out and make the rounds on reddit and TMC. If they'd stop making the rounds with re-edits and rehashes and summations I'd leave it alone. But repeating the same opinion over and over again doesn't make it more accurate.
The chips are Nvidia designed. Nvidia is fabless so they definitely didn't make the chips or the board. It was probably TSMC making the chips and then FoxConn or one of those folks making the board. The PCB design could have been either Nvidia or Tesla, it really doesn't matter. That's common stuff.
That's a thousand times more accurate than anything munro said about the significance of that board.
Now if Munro meant the software that goes with that board or the total system of sofware + hardware then yes it is advanced and traditional car makers in Detroit need to pay attention to what Tesla is doing. But if he wasn't including the software and was just going gaga over the hardware that board isn't that significant. Any car manufacturer can pay to have a similar board made right now. They just won't have the software to go with it and won't have it integrated into the design of the cars they are making in the factory right this second.
Maybe, just maybe I'm being pedantic and discounting Munro's praise because of the words he chose. Or more likely, he didn't phrase it well, didn't qualify his statements well, didn't setup the praise well, all because he doesn't know the tech well.
I found it slightly amusing and interesting the first time through, I have less patience to watch his statements used as a soundbite over and over in followup videos.