I finally pulled my pump, scraped off all the black silicone, and opened it up. About a teaspoon of water came out. I dried and cleaned the board. It had no visible damage that I could see. In fact, it looked great. I reassembled and did a quick test and it's working. What would you guys recommend I seal it with? I have some fish tank silicone.
Do you think I should leave the silicone off the bottom? What about adding a weep hole (done while the board is removed ;-)