I ended up getting one of these:
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07B9KJSCF
It's not as fancy (or expensive) as the leather one -- but I like how utilitarian it is over the other options because it has a key ring for the valet stands.
Reminds me of paying for my wedding. Stick the word "Tesla" in the description of something and charge 2-3 times as much as something should cost.
Fuel Card Holder Key Chain / Gas Card Key Ring - ID Keychain by Specialist ID | eBay
10 Rigid Fuel Card Holders w/ Key Chain - Keychain Ring for Badges Specialist ID | eBay