Model 3 OEM wheels on Model Y, works!

[thwang99]

Some users have replaced the Model Y 19" LR wheels with Model 3 wheels (19" to 18") in an attempt to get better ride quality. I've done it and want to provide my feedback. Here's an example video that explains the reasoning of doing this:

I just took delivery of a model Y 2022, and put on model 3 OEM wheels 2022. The tires I used were "Scorpion AS Plus 3" versus what is recommended in video above (Continental DWS06 plus), because the Continental are not rated for SUV while the Scorpion is. Everything fits and works! The ride quality definitely has improved, though it is still more on the "sporty" side. I reused the TPMS from my OEM wheels. I would do this again, hope this data point can help others.

 

[rivets]

This is great news! I've always preferred the 3 18" wheels over the MYLR 19" wheels. Now, any idea if this will also work on a MYP to clear the brake calipers?

 

[thesmokingman]

This is great news! I've always preferred the 3 18" wheels over the MYLR 19" wheels. Now, any idea if this will also work on a MYP to clear the brake calipers?

Won't work on MYP as it won't clear the rear calipers. The wheels themselves aren't the issue, its the offset + rim width that may pose a problem and then the tire load rating.

 

[JohnB007]

I believe there was a post that analyses this in detail with wheel load chart. I believe the conclusion was that it is ok as long as you load your vehicle carefully. One of the axle was pretty close to the limit even when the Y is carrying no cargo, but when empty, no issues.

 

[DanDi58]

I believe there was a post that analyses this in detail with wheel load chart. I believe the conclusion was that it is ok as long as you load your vehicle carefully. One of the axle was pretty close to the limit even when the Y is carrying no cargo, but when empty, no issues.

Well, if by 'loading carefully', you mean 'load less'. You shouldn't assume that the load ratings and carrying capacity for the MY with 18" wheels is the same as with 19" wheels.

 

[nate704]

I believe there was a post that analyses this in detail with wheel load chart. I believe the conclusion was that it is ok as long as you load your vehicle carefully. One of the axle was pretty close to the limit even when the Y is carrying no cargo, but when empty, no issues.

negligible issue. As the poster above said, as long as the center bore size, wheel lug pattern, offset for clearance, and no rubbing when turning, you should be fine with any wheel/tire combo.

 

[JohnB007]

negligible issue. As the poster above said, as long as the center bore size, wheel lug pattern, offset for clearance, and no rubbing when turning, you should be fine with any wheel/tire combo.

All I'm saying is that there was a in-depth study on this. I'm not an expert on this topic, but clearly others know more. I would read up on those before making any conclusions...

 

[thwang99]

All I'm saying is that there was a in-depth study on this. I'm not an expert on this topic, but clearly others know more. I would read up on those before making any conclusions...

I think this is the in depth study I think you were referring to? One solution may be to look for a 2021 Model 3 wheel or newer. They will be rated for 750kg per wheel. The previous one was 700kg per wheel, based on this:

18" Aero wheels and Model Y load limits

Clarification on the 2021 stock M3 18" Aero wheels. The do have a 750 KG rating, making them have the same load limits (with correct tires) as the 20" induction wheels of 3,300 lbs front and rear. https://teslamotorsclub.com/tmc/attachments/pxl_20210813_131310666-jpg.696024/ Keith

teslamotorsclub.com

750kg would make the wheel ok according to the analysis.

 

[ElectricAnt54]

This is great news! I've always preferred the 3 18" wheels over the MYLR 19" wheels. Now, any idea if this will also work on a MYP to clear the brake calipers?

T-sportline now sells 18” wheels which work on both MYP & MYLR. Search on YouTube for videos about them.

 

[Megavik]

255/45/20 on Model Y perf