I was told that the Pirellis would be stiffer with a rougher ride. I don't notice a rougher ride at all, but feel more in control in the Pirellis.
Value is the key factor. Mine was a misquote above. The blowout actually occurred at 20,000 miles with the Continentals. I think the OEMs might be a cheaper tire than the replacements. Had my tread read by Tesla on my new Raven (with OEM Continentals) after roughly 2,000 miles and the service rep told me they were at a 7 all the way around! New tires at a 7 Geez! Can't wait to get the Continentals off my Raven. I don't feel safe with them and the company is totally unresponsive to any negotiation. 2016 going strong with 6/7 readings on the Pirellis after 20,000 miles. Guaranteed to 65,000. Can't beat that.