I just got a loaner Model S P90D today, and first impression is that both cars drive similarly, though of course the Model S is much lower and handles better. Two obvious things stood out in the first 30 minutes I drove it: regenerative braking is not as strong as in the X, and the stock sound system in the X is much better and immediately noticeable. I'm not a big fan of the S low profile tires as they don't feel very forgiving, but they do look good.
-
Want to remove ads? Register an account and login to see fewer ads, and become a Supporting Member to remove almost all ads.
Model X vs S
- Thread starter rainforest
- Start date
-
- Tags
- Model X
Super_Popular
Well-Known Member
Mark Z
Active Member
Just took delivery of a Model S 90D (19" wheels) with all options except rear facing seats. I am impressed with the quieter interior sound level on noisy concrete freeways compared with my 2012 Signature P85. It has great acceleration and handling with a similar luxury feel like Model X. Before the purchase, I decided that Model S was a better fit for me for the style, efficiency, and convenience. It also helped when friends who were driven in both Model S and Model X decided they enjoyed riding in Model S. They may have a different attitude today with the 5 seat Model X that I think everyone should consider since it has very practical Model S style fold down seat functionality.
While I loved the Big Sky windshield of Model X, having the sun blocked more often with Model S is enjoyable. Now I only have to wear a visor band if the sun is at a bad angle with the sunroof.
Above all, everyone considering Model S or X should sit in the driver's seat and attach the seatbelt for awhile. Adjust the seats and see if the non-moveable Model S seatbelt is too high. If it is, then consider an older used Model S with the lower shoulder seat belt position or try Model X with the adjustable shoulder seat belt.
Choose what is best for you and your passengers to enjoy the pleasure of driving a Tesla electric vehicle.
While I loved the Big Sky windshield of Model X, having the sun blocked more often with Model S is enjoyable. Now I only have to wear a visor band if the sun is at a bad angle with the sunroof.
Above all, everyone considering Model S or X should sit in the driver's seat and attach the seatbelt for awhile. Adjust the seats and see if the non-moveable Model S seatbelt is too high. If it is, then consider an older used Model S with the lower shoulder seat belt position or try Model X with the adjustable shoulder seat belt.
Choose what is best for you and your passengers to enjoy the pleasure of driving a Tesla electric vehicle.
NikeWings
Active Member
I love them both, and like any two cars, they each have their "bests". (Low profile tires on both.)
But, I take the S because I love the open pano, unless its rainy or cold when I love being in the X especially with a storm overhead.
If I had to pick one, it would be the S without hesitation.
But, I take the S because I love the open pano, unless its rainy or cold when I love being in the X especially with a storm overhead.
If I had to pick one, it would be the S without hesitation.
P85DBeast
Side tEsLa
Personally I like the Model S design better. The X looks kinda weird but that doesn't mean I wouldn't own one.
hill
high fiber member
@rainforest you didn't mention soc of either vehicle so it may simply be the model x charge was more full. That would account for the different regen feel - in addition to weight difference. We've had both & notice no difference.
Super_Popular
Well-Known Member
Personally I like the Model S design better. The X looks kinda weird but that doesn't mean I wouldn't own one.
I thought it looked weird too, until I saw a black one with black 22"s.....
HabitualUser
Member
I prefer the X for the height - easier to get in/out for my old self. And I like sitting higher while driving, it feels safer to me.
Peteybabes
redneck drivin' a tesla...
honestly the S looks a bit better to me, but i'm a big dude and the X spoils me
MTOman
Member
Coming from a single motor S to a dual motor X I can tell a huge difference in regen, the X is much stronger, I love it. I suspect this is due to the dual motor because I felt the same thing with a dual motor loaner S.
I was super worried about moving from the S to the X, I obsessed over it for months. I really loved my S and couldn't imagine loving another vehicle as much. I was worried the X wouldn't drive the same, would feel cumbersome and not nimble, I was worried it was too ugly (the pictures on the order page aren't the most flattering, IMHO), I was worried it wouldn't have enough storage space, I was worried I was going to miss things about my S like the sunroof.
In the end, I love the X even more than the S! It's noticeably faster than my S was and I actually prefer the slightly more cushioned feeling of the X on standard height, when put it on the low settings it feels more like my S used to. I don't think it's ugly in person, though the S is still a better looking vehicle. I will say this, the X definitely draws a bigger crowd than my S when those FW doors open I absolutely love the windshield and would take it any day over a sunroof I only occasionally used. All in all I'm very happy I made the switch, though occasionally a tear still collects in the side of my eye when I think about my old S
I was super worried about moving from the S to the X, I obsessed over it for months. I really loved my S and couldn't imagine loving another vehicle as much. I was worried the X wouldn't drive the same, would feel cumbersome and not nimble, I was worried it was too ugly (the pictures on the order page aren't the most flattering, IMHO), I was worried it wouldn't have enough storage space, I was worried I was going to miss things about my S like the sunroof.
In the end, I love the X even more than the S! It's noticeably faster than my S was and I actually prefer the slightly more cushioned feeling of the X on standard height, when put it on the low settings it feels more like my S used to. I don't think it's ugly in person, though the S is still a better looking vehicle. I will say this, the X definitely draws a bigger crowd than my S when those FW doors open
I absolutely love the windshield and would take it any day over a sunroof I only occasionally used. All in all I'm very happy I made the switch, though occasionally a tear still collects in the side of my eye when I think about my old S 
Jrogville
Member
I can so relate. I love my S, but I'm getting too old and my leg bothers me getting in and out of such a low car. I'm about to switch to an X for the height, and the general tone of this thread bolsters my decision. Of course, it's probably to be expected, given this the Model X forum, but still....Coming from a single motor S to a dual motor X I can tell a huge difference in regen, the X is much stronger, I love it. I suspect this is due to the dual motor because I felt the same thing with a dual motor loaner S.
I was super worried about moving from the S to the X, I obsessed over it for months. I really loved my S and couldn't imagine loving another vehicle as much. I was worried the X wouldn't drive the same, would feel cumbersome and not nimble, I was worried it was too ugly (the pictures on the order page aren't the most flattering, IMHO), I was worried it wouldn't have enough storage space, I was worried I was going to miss things about my S like the sunroof.
In the end, I love the X even more than the S! It's noticeably faster than my S was and I actually prefer the slightly more cushioned feeling of the X on standard height, when put it on the low settings it feels more like my S used to. I don't think it's ugly in person, though the S is still a better looking vehicle. I will say this, the X definitely draws a bigger crowd than my S when those FW doors open
Super_Popular
Well-Known Member
You will love the X. No more bending down to look at traffic lights, no more hitting the B pillar, gorgeoue windshield, cooled seats, Falcon doors, auto front door. The X's is an amazing vehicle.
Last edited:
MTOman
Member
Getting in and out of the X is sooo much easier than the S! My dad told me misses how beautiful my S was but loves the X because he can get in and out of it so easily. I like that I don't hit my head anymore getting in and out, something I was doing on a regular basis in my S
Your name wouldn't be Ludvig by any chance?Getting in and out of the X is sooo much easier than the S! My dad told me misses how beautiful my S was but loves the X because he can get in and out of it so easily. I like that I don't hit my head anymore getting in and out, something I was doing on a regular basis in my S
P85DBeast
Side tEsLa
We should really rent an X for a week to see if we agree with all of these quirks. That you dont get in the S. If my wife likes it then..........HEY! She's going to get a 100D X. It might be good to give our garage some diversity. lol
