Can't say for sure, but from their desceiption on both websites, they seem to be pretty much the same to me. Same material, same look.
You have a good point for the mat of the 3rd row, I haven't seem any like that yet..
I’m lucky most of the accessories on my 2020 LR AWD will transfer to our new PMY so I only need a matte screen protector, so with all the money I saved I ordered these from TSportLine so I can retire the 21” tires/wheels on day one - TST 18" Tesla Model Y Wheel and Tire Package (Set of 4) in Space Gray.