MYLR insurance recommendation for Bay Area

[mbill002]

Hi I am shopping for insurance for a MYLR to be delivered this month. Most rates are super high. I got the following:

State Farm: $384/mo
Connect (Costco): $282/mo
Progressive: They don’t have MY under 2023
Tesla: $295/mo
Geico (current provider for a non Tesla): $145/mo (Way cheaper than rest)

Should I go with Geico? Are there other companies to try? Also what are the coverage amount recommendation?

Thank you all.

 

[skydve1]

I'm not in the bay area, but if you check with an insurance broker, they should be able to shop rates for you amongst a bunch of different companies. I've been an AAA member for 25+years, and they do this. That's how I wound up with Travelers.

Both of my kids (ages 24 & 22) live on their own now, and when they moved out they found insurance via a broker too.
Most recently they used Jerry™ Official Site: Compare & Buy Car Insurance , and they both found great rates.

 

[Dbat]

Hi I am shopping for insurance for a MYLR to be delivered this month. Most rates are super high. I got the following:

State Farm: $384/mo
Connect (Costco): $282/mo
Progressive: They don’t have MY under 2023
Tesla: $295/mo
Geico (current provider for a non Tesla): $145/mo (Way cheaper than rest)

Should I go with Geico? Are there other companies to try? Also what are the coverage amount recommendation?

Thank you all.

metromile. my model 3 is only $47 a month plus 9.4 cents per mile

 

[parrainx]

Tesla for my M3 ended up being the cheapest. $139 first 6. Went up to $147. No accidents, no tickets. Late 30s. Bay Area