I recently had this experience with old vs new tail lights.
Bought my Model Y in Feb 2021. Had condensation in both tail lights and mobile service came out to replace. I thought everything was good until yesterday someone pointed out that my brake lights were not working. Today I dropped off the car at Tesla Service Center for them to fix it immediately as this is a safety issue. Turns out the first mobile service installed the wrong (old) tail lights that weren't compatible with the current connectors.
I can't believe I was driving without working brake lights for over a month now.