It’s a long and detailed post, so grab a cup of coffee and enjoy (I hope)… After putting 750K miles on three Lexus LS sedans (400, 460 and 460L models), I was looking for a new daily driver for my 45K miles/year habit. After watching Tesla since inception, the expansion of the Supercharger network and the expanded range of the 100D finally pushed me over the edge. I took delivery of my 100D on Tuesday, 8/1/17, two weeks after it rolled off the assembly line. 19" wheels, solid glass roof and all options except third row kids’ seats and Full Self-Drive (why pay now when it’s years away?). In eight days, I have logged 2,100 miles on a combination of rural roads, city streets and highways. Here are my first impressions:
Drivetrain: 10/10. 4.2 seconds 0-60 is plenty for me. No need to spend the extra $45K on a P badge, fancy fuse pack and larger motor. Passing acceleration is even better than in the LS, which accelerated well with its 8-speed transmission. Suspension is very similar (LS had air suspension, also), with good steering feel and better cornering. The battery mass really helps the car hold the road. Standard tire size (245/45R19) is the same as on the LS, and I had no desire to run the risk of tire damage from the 21" wheel upgrade on rough roads.
Battery Performance: 9/10. I am heavy on the accelerator and have used the brake very little with regenerative braking set to normal. I'm averaging 310 Wh/mi so far, consuming 330ish cruising flat interstate at 80mph and 275ish at 62 on highways. I have Supercharged three times and home charged (72A) three times. All charging cycles went smoothly. Early takeaways re: batteries: DO NOT short yourself on "extra" capacity when you charge. I ran my batteries down below 20% twice in three days, even though I planned to have 25-30% remaining at each of my next planned charges. On one trip, I drove a little faster than normal (new car fever) and averaged 330Wh/mi -- 10% above rated. On the other, I encountered heavy rain and some water accumulation on the freeway. Running at 80mph through water eats 550-600Wh/mi. Five minutes of that and I consumed most of my reserve charge. As fast as the Supercharger refills the tank, an extra 5-10 minutes is a whole lot better than sweating the unforeseen energy-consuming event on your journey. Props to Tesla's programmers -- the car warned me to slow down and conserve energy both times, although route changes (see my comments in the Maps section) meant I really didn't have to slow down. I think that after I learn the game (trip planning on the hobbled nav system, charging strategies, typical energy consumption on regular routes), everything will be fine.
“Normal” Driving vs. Lexus (ignoring Autopilot for now): 10/10 Adjusting to Tesla's throttle and braking behavior took about 500 miles. Now, the car handles smoothly and feels like a $100K sports sedan should. The ride is not rough or mushy with the standard suspension setting. As my LS has a brake hold feature, I feel very normal driving the Tesla with creep turned off. When I get back into the Lexus, I will probably have to reset my foot/brain linkage for throttle lag and lack of regen speed reduction. First world problem, for sure.
Autopilot: 7/10, and should improve with time and software updates. All of our other vehicles have adaptive cruise control, so Tesla's cruise system felt very familiar and similarly accurate. Relative to Lexus and GM (with only three follow distance options), the seven settings on the Tesla are very nice. I like setting 2. My 100D took about 350 miles to calibrate the cameras before I could engage any of the autopilot features. It's a minor, one time nuisance, but the adaptive cruise functions on my Lexus and GM vehicles worked right out of the box. I wonder if Tesla could allow adaptive cruise to work immediately, with autopilot capability activated after adequate calibration? Once fully active, Autopilot/Autosteer has been nice, but slightly less comforting than I had hoped. A few small concerns: 1) When in the right lane approaching a freeway exit (with no intention of exiting), the car drifts toward the exit before deciding to return to the straight and narrow. I understand the reasons, but it still feels very odd. 2) When Autosteer is activated, the system quickly brings the car to center of lane. As I tend to drive closer to the shoulder (leaving more room between my car and the one in the other lane), the speed/severity of this correction can be alarming to driver, passengers and surrounding drivers. Easy fix – remember to move the car to center of lane before activating. One other negative is the placement of the AutoPilot stalk (lower left of steering column). More than once, my hand has landed on that stalk instead of the turn signal stalk. It's not a holdover from driving the Lexus, as that stalk was on the right side -- a much better place, IMO. I'll adapt, but activating cruise when you're trying to signal is a bit disturbing. I feel bad giving Autopilot a 7/10 score, as it is a very slick system that really does work and has huge potential. The car really can drive itself in a lot of situations. It's just not finished, yet.
Climate Control: 7/10. Cooling is important in the South, and buying a car in August gave me an immediate opportunity to test the A/C. It cools quickly, and the combination of Cabin Overheat Protection and remote A/C start (via the very nice iOS app) make for a pleasant experience on a 95 degree day. Tesla loses a point for the lack of fan speed control during Bioweapon Defense Mode (max fan only), but the rest of the HEPA system definitely does its job. I suggest a software edit that uses max speed by default, but with user option to dial it back as appropriate without the system reverting to normal mode. Another point is lost for the feeling I noticed several times while cruising at 80mph on a 90 degree day. The cabin feeling was that of a system suddenly shifting from A/C mode with recirculation to vent mode (little or no cooling) with exterior air. In the humid Louisiana summer, that change is obvious and unpleasant. I think the system was shunting cooling power to the battery system, but that’s just a guess. Also, the lack of ventilated seats is a downer. My Lexus had ventilated seats with actual cooling as well as vent and heat settings. Hot, humid weather + business clothes + long drive = a rough day, and seat cooling made life a little better. When Tesla introduced ventilated seats, I hoped for the addition of cooling down the road. Seeing the perforated seats dropped from the option list hurt. While the advanced cooling features reduce initial discomfort when entering a hot car and make ventilated seats less necessary, I already miss them. Life’s a series of trade offs, though…
Interior: 8.5/10, (vs. the Lexus' 9.5). I chose black premium (leather? – no one seems to know for sure) with the figured ash wood décor and black headliner. No major interior quality issues, but I have a sneaking suspicion that I won't like the fit and finish as much after 7 years / 270K miles as in the Lexus. Road noise is minimal. With no engine noise, some drivers have complained about the level of tire and wind noise, but it’s very comparable to the sound in my Lexus, which had a barely audible engine noise at cruising speed. The cabin is comfortable and generally well laid out, but there’s no good place for trash. Most cars have door pockets that have served me well. Right now, I’m using the cupholders in the armrest as a trash bin (with my giant Yeti in the very nice, adjustable / removable center console cup holder), but I’m looking for a better option. Suggestions appreciated…
Exterior: 9/10. The paint job (midnight silver metallic) looks good, and the body panels fit together nicely. I’ll remove the front license plate holder as soon as I find the right screwdriver bit. Tesla wisely bolted it on from underneath, so there will be no ugly holes in the bumper cover after removal. The standard 19” silver slipstream wheels are rather bland, and the grey version did not become available until after I ordered. At $2,500, I probably wouldn’t have ordered them. I probably will buy aftermarket rims (including one for the spare) and list the OEM set on eBay (let me know if you need a set, summer/winter drivers out there). My only real exterior complaint is that I have to slam the doors to get a complete close. Every person who has closed a door on my car has failed on the first attempt. My LS460 has an automatic door close feature that pulls the door closed the last ½ inch, which is very nice. Slamming a fancy car’s door seems tacky and unnecessary.
Maps / Navigation: 0/10. Tesla, Google, Waze and SpaceX are all interwoven parts of Elon Musk’s domain. Three of the four have amazing navigational systems, yet the Google maps system in my 100D is AWFUL! It selects inefficient routes, does not allow me to choose from alternate routes and – worst of all – has no capacity for planning a multi-leg trip. This is a $100K self-driving car built in 2017 by a guy who lands rockets on barges, and it won’t let me add a stop along my route? If I plot a course from San Francisco to New York, it will add all the necessary Supercharger stops and projected charge times/levels along the way, but if I want to deviate 100 miles to visit a friend, it may leave me stranded without enough charge to get to the next Supercharger unless I manually do the mileage math and adjust my charging stops/times. To me, this is an unforgivable oversight. If I had known about this limitation, I probably would have delayed my purchase until the feature was added.
Financial Analysis: I compared the 100D with a new Lexus LS460, using as similar a build as possible considering one is a traditional ICE luxury sedan and the other is a world-changing lithium-powered vehicle built with little consideration of the “rules of carmaking”. The Lexus has an MSRP $32K below the 100D, but with tax incentives, energy savings (I assumed 60% of charging would be on the free Supercharger network) and maintenance differential (no oil, transmission, etc. changes), the total cost of ownership across 270K miles was similar, with Tesla winning by about $6K). My insurance costs are similar, as well, so it came down to a choice between a fourth Lexus LS model and a totally new driving experience. The eight year, unlimited mileage powertrain warranty was critical to me, as I plan to put 270K miles on the car during that time. The free Supercharging, while not a huge savings (under $6K over 270K miles assuming 60% of all charging at Tesla chargers, by my estimation), was also a big draw, as I want to enjoy the feeling of “free energy” every time I Supercharge, even if the cost was buried in the MSRP.
Misc. Features and Observations: 1) I was shocked to find that there was no smart rain-sensing wiper function on the 100D. Various forum posts say “It’s coming, be patient”, but if a $20K Chevy has smart wipers, why not this car – NOW? 2) The thumb scroll wheels on the steering wheel feel a bit unusual. A function that requires the push of the scroll wheel gives me the feeling that the wheel is going to scroll before I get the button pressed. I find myself being very deliberate in the push action. In a self-driving car, that shouldn’t be a problem (I have extra brain cycles to devote to pressing buttons if I’m not driving the car), but I don’t care for the tactile experience relative to five or six other steering wheel control systems I have used. 3) If Autopilot is engaged and you accelerate past 90 (passing a car, avoiding a merging vehicle, etc.), the system disables Autopilot. That’s fine, and it’s noted in the manual. What I wasn’t prepared for was the penalty: No more Autopilot for the rest of the drive. No “three strikes” (like with the hands on wheel reminder) and no yellow card – just an immediate red card. 4) No spare tire. I understand it’s a growing trend, and I’m glad that Tesla didn’t use the “you don’t need one, because we sold you run-flat tires” line. Regular tires are superior, IMO, and don’t get me started on the “Fix-a-Flat option”. Roadside assistance is fine if you drive in urban areas, but when I have a flat 60 miles from the nearest red light and have an important meeting to attend, there’s no room for a two hour wait. I don’t mind buying a spare (plus a jack and tools), but there’s no good place to store it. Before the addition of the HEPA filter, the frunk was large enough for at least an emergency spare. Now, it will have to live in the trunk, probably wrapped in the nice $40 Tesla Tire Tote, which will facilitate removal when I need extra storage. 5) Where should the tow bolt live? As delivered, it was loose in the trunk well. Hearing a loud THUD when cornering on my way out of the dealership parking lot wasn’t pleasant. I’ve wrapped it in a beach towel and jammed it behind/under the charging cable bag for now. Once I add a full size spare, I’ll put it in the bag with the jack and tools. 6) The upgraded audio system sounds good, but seems to fall short of the Mark Levinson in my Lexus. I’m having trouble balancing front and rear speakers for various musical styles. Voices on hands free phone calls seem weak and hollow relative to the Lexus, as well. Callers report hearing minimal road noise, as in the Lexus.
Summary: 8/10 so far. It’s too early to deliver final grades, but I’m pleased with my purchase.