Looking for opinions so all viewpoints welcome. I have a Model S and have had it over 3 years now. Love the car. I have been trying to convince the wife to try a Model X (she likes a little higher seating position and the option to carry more than 5 people from time to time). Currently she is in a Range Rover Sport and we have looked at the XC90 (I really like it, but her not as much) and the MDX (we have owned a few and they are a good value and safe). If you were looking at a Model X that did not have the PUP what sort of hit on resale would it cause in your opinion and would it be a much harder sell? Please keep in mind I am looking at the White interior which would mean the PUP would not add the leather lower dash and door panels like it would on the Black or Tan Leather versions (yet costs the same which is a bit of a rip-off as I see it). I see the only "upgrades" on the PUP to be ventilated seats, which I like the look of, but I tried the on the X and they don't seem to work well compared to other brands I have tried; the Alcantara, which I like but my wife could care less about I think, the self presenting drivers door which I think is a little gimmicky and a source of some debate here on TMC, and the lighting of the door panels (I think since I have never seen if there is less lighting on the door panels of the non-PUP or no lighting at all on them). The foglights/cornering lights and Biodefense options are not really a huge factor to me but maybe huge to others and affect resale value more than I think. Overall, I just don't think $4500 is worth the price but if I was going to sell a car without it I wonder how much less I would get for it than a PUP car that was otherwise identical? Logic says options are never worth as much on resale as the original cost of them, but it could be that certain options make a car a very hard sell without them and might in turn affect resale much more than I might think. For example, Jeep offered the Wrangler unlimited for a few years as a 2 Wheel drive only model and they are hard to sell at least around here, which drives the price down more than it usually would. I know certain options don't hold value well at all (I am looking at you Ludicrous option!) and others seem to add a lot in value and also make for a much easier sell (it seems like the jump seats on the model S are in this group). What do you all think about the Model X PUP in that regard?