That's the confusion I think. The Model Y performance NON PUP is supposed to come with the red underlined badge and carbon spoiler. The spoiler is even shown on the monroney sticker for performance NON PUP cars. Early Performance NON PUPs have been shipping without them for some reason (current theory is to speed production).
The PUP only adds:
- Increased top speed from 145mph to 155mph
- 21’’ Überturbine Wheels
- Performance Brakes
- Lowered suspension
- Aluminum alloy pedals
Notice no mention of a Carbon spoiler in that list. All other performance trim items should come with the non pup trims as well.
On the other side of the coin, we are seeing AWD models with VIN numbers that would indicate that they are a performance model (which they are not).