And I just thought it was all about the pony. Oh well...Do I miss the rep system? Yes. Nor do I think it should have been a clean sweep. But it appears it was. And as I said to one of you in the last day, talking about how much rep I could give out was not at the top of my list at parties. My friends would look at me like I lost my mind.
Yes, I think we're losing some data and that data should have been just as protected as posts and links. It should have been given the same care in the platform transfer as any other data. It was a reward system for members who have added value to this forum. But in the grand scheme of things, it doesn't matter.
It doesn't matter because I don't believe I've written a post thinking, 'This will get me rep!'. I've written my opinion. Getting points from my fellow forum members has been a welcome bonus in the past.
doug
Administrator / Head Moderator
Sadly, this was also used to send anonymous insults.
ohmman
Plaid-ish Moderator
No wonder I got so much rep.
Seriously, though.. that never occurred to me. What irony to give rep only to insult someone.
brianman
Burrito Founder
- Nov 10, 2011
- 17,515
- 2,980
Non-anonymous feedback through the old rep channel had no downsides afaik. Too bad it wasn't easy to force the non-anonymous part.
Agreed.
I'd occasionally get a comment and I had no idea who left it (never anything bad)
bonnie
I play a nice person on twitter.
Was it really abused that much? I seem to remember a few cases, but only a handful. Did that change? (My personal experience has been that no one has had a problem insulting me publicly
, so hearing that this was a problem is a surprise.)
danny
Administrator
omarsultan
Active Member
Gizmotoy
Active Member
I've received a few insults via rep in the past, though never anonymously (they signed it!). I think the intent was to skirt the "Report a Post" feature.
bonnie
I play a nice person on twitter.
Hah. It never occurred to them to send you a pm instead? At least you got rep points for it.
FlasherZ
Sig Model S + Sig Model X + Model 3 Resv
- Jun 21, 2012
- 7,024
- 1,013
Was it really abused that much? I seem to remember a few cases, but only a handful. Did that change? (My personal experience has been that no one has had a problem insulting me publicly
It happened to me somewhat frequently. When I would warn others of a dangerous charging installation (say, someone who posted that it's just fine to leave a neutral unconnected on a 14-50), I'd get negative rep hits ("I can do what I want!"). While I didn't debate the "I can do what I want" point, I wanted to make sure that others understood how dangerous it was.
bonnie
I play a nice person on twitter.
That was when folks could give negative rep. I think doug was saying that people would give positive rep, but as a way to give anonymous negative feedback in the comment line. And I was asking if that really happened very often.
FlasherZ
Sig Model S + Sig Model X + Model 3 Resv
- Jun 21, 2012
- 7,024
- 1,013
Oh, never to me. Even if they did, I'd be happy knowing that they donated to the green bar & pony fund.
Gizmotoy
Active Member
Too late now! Best I can do is click the Dislike button with full attribution. How's that work for you?
tomas
Out of warranty...
Brave call, glad you made it, as the old rep system was becoming a bit unhinged. The name was inadequate, it would be more fitting to call it popularity points or similar. People gave points for all sorts of reasons.
Contributors in polarized heated topics had a greater chance of giving and receiving points. Such topics attracted traffic, including high rep power members presence and that skewed the rep points distribution to polarized content and drama.
I have concerns about assigning any visual comparative metrics to TMC members and giving that metric some name that signifies qualitative value, like reputation. Equating accumulated votes on the anonymous forum to any qualitative metric is likely to be incorrect. It might be better to call it what it is, something from the fun and games repertoire. My opinion, but not my call.
My view is that if Elon Musk posted his views on TMC incognito, he would be unlikely to garner many votes, or at least, he perhaps would not make it to top group.
That was my favorite feature, I miss that as well, perhaps even more than my vanity bars. Sending unsolicited email is a bit intrusive, too big hurdle to cross to give feedback on a single post.
Last edited:
brianman
Burrito Founder
- Nov 10, 2011
- 17,515
- 2,980
Completely disagree. He would make some of the most interesting posts -- like he does without even coming here.
Johan
Ex got M3 in the divorce, waiting for EU Model Y!
Yes but Auzies saying he wouldn't earn a lot of reputation points in the old system (better called popularity contest points). I agree.
In some threads, the arguments are sometimes won on the back of being 'popular' ie having many green bars, rather than on the merits of knowledge and facts. New members are sometimes shouted down on the back of being new members.
Afaik seniority (time-based) and popularity are not valid arguments in technical discussions.
Similar threads
