This isn't a case where a Tesla driver killed themselves playing around with the Tesla software. This is a case where the Tesla driver killed someone else using the software in basically the manner in which it is intended to be used. If the software is going to make mistakes like this (and simulate a rude and inattentive driver who doesn't care about lane change signals), it probably shouldn't have been released onto the public roads. But since it was released onto the public roads, Tesla should be liable to the people it kills. Other drivers on the road didn't agree to be part of Tesla's experiment in rushing out "Beta" software. Tesla created a dangerous toy. It should be liable for what the toy does to other drivers when the toy is used by a Tesla operator in a normal way (like driving straight on the freeway).
Have you read the Tesla user manual at all? And in particular, the clear warnings about being attentive and being prepared to take over in an emergency?
AP is basically a more sophisticated cruise control. Do you expect every car crash involving
any form of cruise control to be blamed on the car maker? If not, why is Tesla different? What specific features, documented by Tesla, do you think makes them liable for not preventing this tragedy?
Traditional dumb cruise control would
never have prevented an accident like that. Today's smarter cruise controls, like AP, can indeed prevent some accidents such as these. You seem to be saying that is a bad thing .. that we should either have
perfect smart cruise control (good luck waiting for that!) or go back to dumb cruise control which doesnt prevent
any accidents at all. That seems ridiculous to me.
Or are you saying the driver was lulled into a feeling that they didn't need to pay attention because it was "auto pilot"? Again, go read the Tesla manual, and see what it clearly says. If the driver
did think he could sit back and not bother paying attention, then isnt the liability
clearly on the driver for not understanding how to use the system?
Of
course this accident was a tragedy, every accident like this is, no matter where the blame lies. But knee-jerk hysterical reactions to things like this are stupid. Go watch YouTube and see the times the safety systems on the Tesla have
prevented serious accidents. And then reflect on what you are saying, which is apparently that the car should not have such safety systems.