Hi there! Find My Electric here...we can comment on this.
So, CarBuyerUSA is a legit site as far as we can tell--they do buy a lot of vehicles (not just Teslas), and we've also heard that their offers come in at a pretty decent price.
That said, we've also heard some problems with them. Since they buy gas cars too, they aren't Tesla experts. We've also heard their customer service isn't too good (as stated in their Google reviews), and that the process can be kind of difficult.
A better solution? Request an offer from us--Find My Electric!
We are Tesla experts, and our Instant Cash Offer program is unique in that we bring multiple EV dealers (not random gas car dealers) together from around the country in one place to compete against each other and give you multiple offers!
You can also list your Tesla for sale on our site for free (or upgrade to a paid listing).
If you haven't requested an offer from us,
you can do it in 2 minutes here!
We're also an approved TMC vendor--any questions, feel free to reach out!