Yep, agreed. That's what I've considered and why I originally was leaning towards letting the calls get exercised.Two other ways to look at it:
1. On the other side of that trade is a Call Buyer who thinks that SP will increase by more than $15 between now and 6/17. Who is more likely to be right?
2. If you close now and invest .. say buy 2/3 back of your shares after taking the loss. By 6/17 will shares gain you make more or less than rolling CC?
I think it would only take SP gain of ~$25 to make more.
As we've seen over the past 3 months, it's a crap shoot in the short term as to whether the SP goes up or down. I'm good with hedging my holdings a bit longer by rolling the CCs. Worst case (for the CCs) is the SP continues to rise. I'm good with that as my CCs are just on a fraction of my shares. But given the run-up we've had the last two weeks, I could also see P&D being a sell-the-news event, in which case I'm glad I rolled my CCs.