Interesting questions.
Regarding the closes yesterday vs. today, not questioning them in the least. Then again once I make a trade the only question I ask myself later is whether there was something I knew, when I made the trade, that I would use in the future to make the trade differently. Its more of a process thing for me, rather than optimizing an individual trade.
In that context, yesterday's closes ticked off all my boxes for an early close:
- high % gain (not much of a motivator, but it does help to know how much is left to earn)
- high absolute gain. More of a motivator
- big drop in the share price (close cc's on down days)
- closing early also enables an open on the next up day that is frequently the next day (never open a replacement position on a day where a position is closed)
- in this case, since the uptick rule got triggered, today being flat to up was nearly guaranteed in my mind. At the least a big down day wasn't in the offing.
I also used market orders for all of those opens and closes - once I've decided I like the new position (opening or closing), I just do it and don't sweat the pennies. The market orders frequently get me the mid point, and that is plenty good for me. I've explained the logic elsewhere.
Anyway - by closing yesterday at really high % gains I had no overnight thought or worry about today. I expected an up day - I was hoping for a bigger move up today. The only reason for the expectation was the big move down plus the fact it reached 10% / triggered the uptick rule. Little or no stomach acid is a biggie for me, and I'm finding the buy-writes to work REALLY REALLY well for me in this regard.
On a bigger move up I would have been able to open an even better strike and/or premium. And the $7.50ish open is a great position for me. If I close at 2/3rds then that'll be a $5 realized result for next week. And the 700 strike, even if it gets overrun, means I'll take a $20 loss when I sell the shares. I'll have collected north of $70 over the 4 weeks for a net $50 plus the $7 - $57 over 4 weeks makes for some excellent dividend like result action.
Oh - and I was closing 650s and 680s - now I have 700s (lots better strike) for next week.
In summary - for dividend like income this week has worked out great. Next week is lined up to be great, and as this is cash I would otherwise be using to sell cash secured puts, I'm not nearly as attached to the shares as I would otherwise be. If we go to 700ish next week then I'd probably roll to $10 or $20 OTM but if we get to 750 or 800ish then I just well the shares when I close the cc's and am excited about the net result ($20 share loss, $70+ premiums). And I'll even be happy having that cash again
If somehow we drifted up week to week then I'd have the best of all worlds - a steadily improving cc strike as well as big weekly credits.
More likely we'll have a sharp move up that will push time value close to 0 - I'll use that as an early close opportunity, watch the share price drop the next day, and start a new buy-write.