@bhzmark Thanks, those comparisons are super helpful!
Wife and I have a January 2013 P85 (soft air suspension) and 2021 M3P, and we've driven many S over the years, including coil spring originals, P85+, P85D+, P100DL, lots of 75s and 90s, etc. Big range of suspension tuning over the years, and I know exactly what you mean by loose and floaty on the pre-plus and post-plus suspensions. Last year we were back and forth on ordering a new S but couldn't pull the trigger without a test drive.
The yoke was part our trepidation of course but we also wanted more certainty about how the suspension handles and feels. Early descriptions here seemed all over the map - some said very smooth, some said too stiff and bouncy (regardless of adjustment settings). It wasn't clear what everyone's baseline was. Having direct comparisons with multiple older S suspensions is really useful!
Of course it doesn't help us that my favorite S suspension was the P85+, while my wife's favorite was the P100DL floaty tank. But Plaid Track Mode might allow for the range of adjustment needed to make us both happy.
(Though I do wish we could get S Track Mode without paying up for the Plaid, we really don't need Plaid power, but I know it'll never happen...Tesla will only release Track Mode for the top performance model.)