Alright, it’s finally in!
What happened was that the cubby was indeed unclipped. Once I got it back in, everything fit much better.
I did remove the end plastic piece that was held by 4 small screws and washers in the process and it made fitting it a lot easier. After fitting it, I put that piece back and pressed up up against the wall as much as possible to hold the console in place; however, maybe because of that, the console didn’t fit very snug and has some wiggle room. To make it steady, I wedged a couple microfiber towels in between the end of the console and the yatcht floor end under the cubby/screen and it was secure!
View attachment 405719 View attachment 405721
It’s does look pretty awesome! The black is a bit darker than the black in my car, but it still looks really good overall.
Thanks for al the help!