Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register
  • We just completed a significant update, but we still have some fixes and adjustments to make, so please bear with us for the time being. Cheers!

Tax Credit Clarification

spiderguy

Member
Oct 20, 2014
83
44
Bay Area
Question: there is a 200,000 car sale trigger. Got it and I understand the phaseout parts. But does EVERY car sold in the next phaseout part get covered? If they sell 50,000 or 500,000, is there any trigger that caps the tax credit?

Once the 200,000 vehicle limit is reached, the computation changes to time periods. All that matters is when you receive delivery of your car. As an example, if the 200,000th car is sold on 1/15/18, the full credit is allowable up to 6/30/18. During that 5 1/2 month period, it doesn't matter if Tesla sells 1,000 cars or 1,000,000 cars; they would all receive full credit.
 

neroden

Model S Owner and Frustrated Tesla Fan
Apr 25, 2011
14,676
62,627
Ithaca, NY, USA
However, if you are living off food stamps, DON'T BUY A TESLA!!! Haha, your going to end up living in the car. However, a positive is that if your going to live in it, there seems to be a lot of storage space.

More importantly, you can keep the heat on and go to sleep without risking your life or spending a fortune like you would in a gas car. If you're going to live in a car, a Tesla is absolutely the best car to live in. Talk someone into letting you plug into their outdoor outlet, even at trickle-charging levels, and you have safe heat.

I was actually discussing this hypothetical with someone a few years ago. I think once there are enough old used plug-in cars on the market (which will probably take more than 10 years) this will actually start being a thing.
 

SmarterMotors

Member
Apr 6, 2016
31
65
Rosemead, California
More importantly, you can keep the heat on and go to sleep without risking your life or spending a fortune like you would in a gas car. If you're going to live in a car, a Tesla is absolutely the best car to live in. Talk someone into letting you plug into their outdoor outlet, even at trickle-charging levels, and you have safe heat.

I was actually discussing this hypothetical with someone a few years ago. I think once there are enough old used plug-in cars on the market (which will probably take more than 10 years) this will actually start being a thing.

True that. You can probably just plug at a local supercharger and sleep there through the night. Free heat and power. Stick a power plug adapter into the cigarette lighter and power your devices. There is no carbon monoxide so you don't have to worry about dying from poisoning. Also the car looks pretty sexy so people won't think your homeless and kick you off the premises.

You could totally save big $$$ living in the tesla. Rent free, no power bill.
 
  • Funny
Reactions: MP3Mike

Az_Rael

Supporting Member
Jan 26, 2016
5,602
8,752
Palmdale, CA
There are people who camp in EVs. Back in the early days, Teslas used to "camp" at RV parks to do cross country trips. Several people who have Volts sleep in them when they travel. An RV park and an electric spot is cheaper than a hotel. And warmer than a tent. :)
 

omarsultan

Active Member
Jun 22, 2013
2,218
4,477
Northern California
Also, if your parents "sell" you a $35k car the following February even for a nominal $1, there's a possibility the sales tax man in your state would want to be paid sales tax based on the fair value of the car (not what you claim as the sales price on the title transfer). Many states have exemptions for family transfers of title but it's something you should double check.

You should check your state laws - here in CA you can transfer cars between family members with little hassle.
 

omarsultan

Active Member
Jun 22, 2013
2,218
4,477
Northern California
At the end of the day, an internet car forum is not where you should be getting tax advice. :) I'd suggest finding a tax advisor in the next year or so who can look at your particular situation and offer advice on how to maximize the tax credit.
 
  • Helpful
Reactions: SW2Fiddler

Darryl

ModelXTracker.com Co-Adm
Jul 27, 2015
609
325
Palm Beach FL
The attachment from SmarterMotor posted only mention that a large number of non model S/X should receive the tax incentive. What exactly does that mean? If you order before the unveiling or under the 115K that was mention. What are the chances of getting the 7500 credits. I understand those that make over $250K don't qualified. Will other car maker such as leaf and bolt dip into the tax credit funds?
There is no $250k income limit on the tax credit. On the other hand it is exactly the opposite. If you don't generate after decductions enough income to generate at least $7500 in tax liability then you may get none or only a part of the credit. Whether you earn enough or not it still goes against the 200k car limit.

I too feel the 200k limit will be consumed with Model S and Model X as I doubt that any model 3 will be delivered before mid-2018. This would mean may be one to two quarters of Model 3's will get the reduced credit and it would be limited to the fully loaded cars ($75k+). Also Tesla in the past has had to limit production over the first few months to minimum number of cars. For example they started X production in September and by January they were still only producing around 200 cars per month. They then had to shut production down for six seeks to resolve production line issue. It wasn't until March they were able to produce around 1500 cars. This mean there was a six month ramp up. If it rakes this long to ramp up the Model 3 very few Model 3 owners will be eligible. They will be lucky to produce $50k -100k cars in the first six months and many of them may be going to other countries in this region. (Like Canada)
 

SageBrush

REJECT Fascism
May 7, 2015
12,101
15,021
New Mexico
I used to feel a little guilty that I was getting to have other people help me be able to afford purchasing an EV through the US Federal tax credit.
I'll add a couple other societal benefits from your purchase:

  1. Your Tesla purchase is keeping money in the US. I have read that a newly printed dollar goes through 9 iterations of sales tax on average during its lifetime.
  2. Your Tesla purchase is keeping manufacturing in the US. Ask CA and NV if they appreciate the Fremont and Giga factories.
  3. You are purchasing electricity (in one form or another) that is mostly or entirely a domestic product, which is a triple benefit: money stays in the US; money does not flow to OPEC; and downward pressure on OPEC prices.
This is far from a complete list, the unrealized (uncounted) benefits from pollution avoidance and reduced pressures to embark on military misadventures is considerable. Take the money with a clean conscience.

Oh, and one other point: this entire notion of paying taxes is part of being a good citizen is not quite as clear cut as we often think. I increasingly view taxation as a redistribution of wealth mechanism with a lot of corruption, inefficiency, and friction built-in. Personally, I'm fine with redistribution, but not so much with the other baggage that government carries.

I think a better question than 'do you pay taxes' is 'what do you do with your money?'
 
Last edited:

Scannerman

Member
Apr 10, 2016
97
40
San Diego
I wonder if they can be "sold" and not made or delivered. Then everyone after the 200,000th can get the credit and just wait. Just a thought.
I am completely new to this forum, and to a large degree, new to all forums. And if my question has already been addressed, please assist me in finding that info.

My question is: How will sequencing for the Federal Rebate be determined? Will it be the time stamp on the reservation, (adjusted for one's local time zone, and employee/owner status), or the time the order is signed, the time the financing is finalized, or the time the vehicle is delivered.

Regarding income requirements, it appears some of you are overlooking the option of leasing, in which case the rebate flows directly to Tesla. And your lease rates should be adjusted accordingly. At least that is the case with Ford Motor Co sale of PHEV's. I know this from first hand experience.

Scannernan
 

Az_Rael

Supporting Member
Jan 26, 2016
5,602
8,752
Palmdale, CA
My question is: How will sequencing for the Federal Rebate be determined? Will it be the time stamp on the reservation, (adjusted for one's local time zone, and employee/owner status), or the time the order is signed, the time the financing is finalized, or the time the vehicle is delivered.

Delivered. The date that is relevant to the IRS form is the vehicles in-service date.

Its going to be a wild ride for those counting on the tax credit. you most likely will have to choose your options and confirm the car without a good status as to what level tax credit you will get if we are close to the phase out period when that happens. I recommend not making any critical financial decisions based on getting the full $7500. treat it like a bonus discount if you get it.
 
Last edited:

DrPhoton

Member
Nov 8, 2015
44
27
San Diego, CA
I'll add a couple other societal benefits from your purchase:

  1. Your Tesla purchase is keeping money in the US. I have read that a newly printed dollar goes through 9 iterations of sales tax on average during its lifetime.
  2. Your Tesla purchase is keeping manufacturing in the US. Ask CA and NV if they appreciate the Fremont and Giga factories.
  3. You are purchasing electricity (in one form or another) that is mostly or entirely a domestic product, which is a triple benefit: money stays in the US; money does not flow to OPEC; and downward pressure on OPEC prices.
This is far from a complete list, the unrealized (uncounted) benefits from pollution avoidance and reduced pressures to embark on military misadventures is considerable. Take the money with a clean conscience.

Oh, and one other point: this entire notion of paying taxes is part of being a good citizen is not quite as clear cut as we often think. I increasingly view taxation as a redistribution of wealth mechanism with a lot of corruption, inefficiency, and friction built-in. Personally, I'm fine with redistribution, but not so much with the other baggage that government carries.

I think a better question than 'do you pay taxes' is 'what do you do with your money?'
I hadn't thought of all that. Very well said.
 

AZ Desert Driver

Rare combination
Mar 12, 2016
1,335
715
Tucson AZ
More benefits of electric:
Catalytic converters can start grass fires.
Platinum in cat-converters is a theft target (cost me and my insurance co $4,500 two years ago + inconvenience factor).

Will resale of EV depreciate as fast as ICE? fear timing belt vs replacement battery.
Modern car (electronic upgrades) vs worn out ICE?

Are you drowning polar bears with your exhaust? (climate change)
My "Conductor" avatar is a chin strap penguin. Saw lots of melting 'bergs in Antartica.
 

James Anders

Member
Mar 13, 2014
892
606
Southampton, PA
Clearly this artificially imposed limit of 200K will have to be extended. Not to do so would be a tacit admission that climate change is no big deal. I really can't see this happening at this crucial time in EV adoption - and when affordable EVs will be sold to the masses.
 

ohmman

Plaid-ish Moderator
Feb 13, 2014
9,921
17,934
North Bay, CA
Clearly this artificially imposed limit of 200K will have to be extended. Not to do so would be a tacit admission that climate change is no big deal. I really can't see this happening at this crucial time in EV adoption - and when affordable EVs will be sold to the masses.
I've said this in other places, but I strongly prefer replacing the existing credit with a more robust incentive program in lieu of extending the existing program. Obviously, if the choices are nothing or extending it, I'm in favor of extending it. But I really feel like it could be much more effectively structured as a rebate program instead of a credit, despite the fact that the public optics favor credits.
 

MP3Mike

Well-Known Member
Feb 1, 2016
15,007
31,899
Oregon
Regarding income requirements, it appears some of you are overlooking the option of leasing, in which case the rebate flows directly to Tesla. And your lease rates should be adjusted accordingly. At least that is the case with Ford Motor Co sale of PHEV's. I know this from first hand experience.

Just so you know Tesla doesn't finance or lease vehicles. They do have partners that do that for them. However, as been covered elsewhere in this thread, the current Tesla leasing partner, for the Model S/X, keeps the tax credit for themselves while increasing the residual value. So it reduces your monthly payment but makes the buyout at the end too expensive. (i.e. If you buy it at the end you get none of the tax credit.)

Of course that could change with the Model 3, but I doubt it.
 

dgpcolorado

high altitude member
Apr 25, 2015
2,478
3,286
The Western Slope, Colorado
A minor point - I don't think there's ever been a cigarette lighter in a Tesla, but there are USB ports you can draw power from.:) It doesn't fundamentally change your point though.
While it is true that my car didn't come with a cigarette lighter insert, it does have the circular 12 V port — located just below the USB ports — that was originally designed for cigarette lighters... I keep a little flashlight insert in mine when I'm not using it for something else. I'd be pretty surprised if your S didn't have one also, but perhaps they eliminated it in later cars.
 

About Us

Formed in 2006, Tesla Motors Club (TMC) was the first independent online Tesla community. Today it remains the largest and most dynamic community of Tesla enthusiasts. Learn more.

Do you value your experience at TMC? Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. As a thank you for your contribution, you'll get nearly no ads in the Community and Groups sections. Additional perks are available depending on the level of contribution. Please visit the Account Upgrades page for more details.


SUPPORT TMC
Top