Its a hard stop.Anyone have an idea how the income limit is going to work? Is it a hard stop if the AGI is $300k and you get $0 in tax incentives for a Model Y? Or will it be a graduated decrease?
You can install our site as a web app on your iOS device by utilizing the Add to Home Screen feature in Safari. Please see this thread for more details on this.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Its a hard stop.Anyone have an idea how the income limit is going to work? Is it a hard stop if the AGI is $300k and you get $0 in tax incentives for a Model Y? Or will it be a graduated decrease?
Tesla Model 3 and Model Y
Both U.S.-made Model 3 sedans and Model Y SUVs, the top selling EVs in America, would qualify for the tax credit following passage, a boost for the brand because Tesla is currently phased out of the tax credit. (Note: Tesla does not break out sales between Model 3 and Model Y, but registration data is used as a proxy.)
However, only the lowest trim Model 3 Rear Wheel Drive qualifies (MSRP $46,990). As for the Model Y, both trims qualify (Long Range - $65,990; Performance - $69,990) assuming the government classifies the Model Y as an SUV.
Reddit has an interesting spreadsheet showing tax credits by make/model with the current law and "guesstimates" for credits with the new law after it is signed.
Reddit EV Tax Credit Spreadsheet
the car itself is made in america so it will at least get the $3750 by defaultMy understanding is that no tesla will be eligble for the ev tax credit anymore bc they dont meet the made in usa requirement for the battery materials.
I think it’s up to $80,000 for truck or SUV so I’d think it’d cover the MY. However it has more to do with where the battery is manufactured and where the minerals for the battery come from. From what I got from it, most Teslas would get approximately 1/2 of the $7500 credit because of this.It's limited to cars under $55k and there are income limits as well. Only the bog standard M3 SR+ would qualify.
Yes! I haven’t read anyone talking about this. CATL (largest vehicle battery manufacturer in the word, also based in China) makes m3 LFP battery, so m3 battery won’t qualify for the battery component portion, though I think it will still qualify for the $3750 assembled in NA requirement.Read one opinion that the m3 rwd would not qualify with the china lfp battery
No, that assembled in N/A applies to batteries in addition to qualifying the car. CATL batteries in the SR Model 3 will not qualify for either half of the credit based on current language. There has been some talk about petitioning the Secretary of Transportation for temporary waivers of some requirements.Yes! I haven’t read anyone talking about this. CATL (largest vehicle battery manufacturer in the word, also based in China) makes m3 LFP battery, so m3 battery won’t qualify for the battery component portion, though I think it will still qualify for the $3750 assembled in NA requirement.
There has been so much mis interpretation of this bill. A sure sign it is very poorly written. So to add to the confusion ... this is another thing I heard. That the battery minerals/build provisions kick in in 2024 not 2023. So there may be a window in 2023 for the M3 RWD if this is true. The Treasury Department is supposed to issue a list of eligible cars later this year. I'm thinking it might take them that long to figure out what the bill says. Until this list comes out who really knows which cars are eligible and for what amounts.No, that assembled in N/A applies to batteries in addition to qualifying the car. CATL batteries in the SR Model 3 will not qualify for either half of the credit based on current language. There has been some talk about petitioning the Secretary of Transportation for temporary waivers of some requirements.
It's hard to get real information about how this will play out. The 2024 deadline may leave the Model Y eligible for the full $7.500 for the year 2023. The Model 3 SR still has the problem of the batteries manufactured in China. No explanation exists whether the raw material delay will or will not allow a partial credit for the SR.There has been so much mis interpretation of this bill. A sure sign it is very poorly written. So to add to the confusion ... this is another thing I heard. That the battery minerals/build provisions kick in in 2024 not 2023. So there may be a window in 2023 for the M3 RWD if this is true. The Treasury Department is supposed to issue a list of eligible cars later this year. I'm thinking it might take them that long to figure out what the bill says. Until this list comes out who really knows which cars are eligible and for what amounts.
Agreed. I’ve read the bill a half dozen times and the language is ridiculously confusing. My understanding is the ‘24 thing is batteries manufactured in “countries of concern” - read China - but the 40% minerals origin/processing and 50% components/assembly by cost is 2023. I find it hard to believe the CATL LFP will qualify without a waiver, but I’ve heard some suggest the cells are actually packaged in USA, so conceivably it could qualify for that half, and, theoretically, 40% of the minerals could have been mined or processed in FTA countries even though it’s manufactured in China, but seems unlikely given how much lithium comes from china and CATL is a Chinese company subsidized by the Chinese government. Ultimately, it all comes down to how the secretary and IRS interpret the bill and if they give waivers in the short term.There has been so much mis interpretation of this bill. A sure sign it is very poorly written. So to add to the confusion ... this is another thing I heard. That the battery minerals/build provisions kick in in 2024 not 2023. So there may be a window in 2023 for the M3 RWD if this is true. The Treasury Department is supposed to issue a list of eligible cars later this year. I'm thinking it might take them that long to figure out what the bill says. Until this list comes out who really knows which cars are eligible and for what amounts.
Paid $2k extra for my red MYP, and I am glad I did because I don't need any free s**t just like this tax credit.No dumber than charging extra (or paying for) a red car vs another color
To be fair, the MSRP caps were the same in BBB last year when the M3LR was well under $55k.The crafters of this bill have set up a series of filters that cleverly eliminates almost all Tesla's, at least for the time being.
- M3 RWD... passes on the price cap, but almost certainly fails on the battery materials and battery assembly. I wasn't sure if the battery is assembled in China or Nevada/Freemont.
- M3LR/Performace..... fails on the price cap. Even if the price drops, it will almost certainly fail the battery materials, but pass on the battery assembly. So maybe half the credit IF the price drops. Otherwise nothing.
- MYLR/Performance.... passes the price cap for SUV (depending on options), but likely to fail on the battery materials, but pass on the battery assembly. So likely half the credit.
But they have really found a way to eliminate partially or fully most of the current EV market.
You can buy FSD later if you can manage the separate financing. Alternatively, you could just subscribe....My configuration is barely over $80k with fsd, so I guess I’d have to remove it to qualify.