POST-DICTION:
1,022,183 shares of TSLA traded in the 4:00 pm minute on Friday. That's extreme volume, with only 20.5M shares total traded on Fri, including Pre-Market and After-hrs sessions:
View attachment 843226
This notably high Closing Cross volume indicates covering of short sales made during the day, and that much of the push down early on Friday was manipulation.
Paging
@Papafox
Throughout the weekend, I've been pondering TSLA's price movements on Friday. It's not as straightforward as most days.
The big question I have is "what price did the market makers want TSLA to close at on Friday"? With max pain around 875 and strikes below 920 dominated by puts, there was a fairly wide range of "acceptable" closing prices that give the MMs lots of profits. With TSLA opening near 895, how much of a pushdown would be optimal for the market makers? TSLA was going to dip because the NASDAQ was on its way to closing down 2%. Market makers could easily tweak the trading so that we saw anywhere from a 2% to 4% dip of TSLA for the day and nobody would think anything out of the ordinary.
Considerations:
* A lot of the strikes were loaded with calls and puts being pretty close to each other. At 890, calls and puts were close to even, and so closing right on the number kept either party with 890 puts or calls from making any money. Notice how level TSLA remained in after hours trading until just right before the 6pm close. Market makers were definitely herding TSLA after hours.
* Would market makers have benefitted more if TSLA closed near the 880ish low? That number was certainly closer to the advertised 875 max pain, and if the MMs had been looking to cover naked shorts on Friday, perhaps this was an attractive option. They certainly could have capped the stock and kept it near 880 through close because the NASDAQ traded all afternoon in a level to somewhat down trajectory. Easy-peasy. Instead, in the low volume afternoon hours we saw TSLA stock rise when no other growth stock was rising.
One possibility
We both noticed that over a million shares trading hands in the closing cross on Friday. What I'm thinking is that the market makers and hedge funds may have given TSLA an extra nudge to get it down about 3% in late morning, but I then think they may have just let the market take it from there so that the stock closed at a price appropriate for the market's appetite, given the morning pushdown. As it turns out, the market wanted to bid the price of TSLA up a bit in the afternoon (particularly if MMs and hedgies were already covering some of their day shorting from the morning dip). That higher price was needed to encourage more sellers in the closing cross, because MMs and hedgies were buying to cover naked shorts (big time!) and you needed LOTS of sellers in the closing cross. Thus, maybe the morning dip was the setup for a lower closing price, the afternoon rise was some day-short covering as well as the market pricing TSLA appropriately, given the morning pushdown, and the closing cross was used by MMs and hedgies to buy lots of shares to close their naked short positions. In other words, much of the day was a setup for a high-volume closing cross at an attractive price. Another variation would be to say the morning pushdown was a setup for covering in the afternoon and during the closing cross. A rising price as the afternoon progressed and a million shares traded in the closing cross suggests there may be more covering yet to do.