And an interesting one...
View attachment 598908
https://twitter.com/cruise/status/1316786478291320834?s=21
I’m really hoping that the rush to keep up with Elon is not going to result in a loss of life on one of these platforms. I’m all for Tesla FSD. No clue about Waymo, Cruise, Uber, and the zillions of others’ reliability.
I don't think its a "rush to keep up with Elon" -- FSD has been "around the corner" going by Elon for quite a while. Forget about Tesla for a minute and consider the Waymo/Cruise approach.
They rely on hi-res mapping and LIDAR with a tendency to rely on proven routes. By using the crutch of LIDAR & mapping they are able to brute force their way to a limited solution. It also makes getting regulatory approval easier: you are asking for a particular region (even a subset of a city) and have high focus on that region.
Then consider the market to be addressed. Waymo and Cruise are after the rideshare market, undercutting it by eliminating the driver. The high cost of LIDAR is not that much of a setback in this approach -- it raises upfront costs, but the recurring revenue will make up for that. In other words, it just extends the ROI.
Its been clear for a while that Waymo would have approved FSD in some market before Tesla does, and Waymo is going for the same market so for Cruise it is Waymo that is the competition.
What about Tesla? A generalized approach is far more powerful, but in consequence requires far more data in order to achieve approval because it isn't being geo-fenced. Also, the market for Tesla FSD is currently the retail market. They are selling it bundled with a car to normal people. All of this puts Tesla in a different place.
I believe that Waymo and Cruise have faith in their approach and thus they see as Tesla pursuing a phantom. They don't care about Tesla, other than maybe concern for bad press about autonomy, but they are ready to loudly clarify how their solution is fundamentally different than Tesla's.
The problem for Waymo and Cruise will be if Tesla achieves a robotaxi release before they have entered enough markets to give them revenue to keep growing while operating. I think that is currently an open question. Last year Waymo had clear intentions on being a robotaxi by end of year, but it looks like that is delayed to this one (the most recent news was that they would gradually expand to being fully open to the public, not that they are right now).
Consider, it took Waymo a year to go from a "complete" solution to an "approved" solution even with the time advantage of LIDAR/geo-fence. How long will it take Tesla? Will their massive data collection compensate for the generality?